@PistolsAtDawn
Why would anyone take you seriously the story a lone makes U4 a better game, visually well there is no argument there U4 is also the winner. You can have a preference but when you start making comments as to why you like one game over the other specially when your argument is the controls which are fine to me makes me wonder and considering your track record everything you say becomes suspect.
Easy way to not get taken seriously by gamers if you honestly don't like U4 it's fine but you have to make your argument for why it's getting deducted otherwise you come off as not being very unknowledgeable, pretentious and a bit condescending towards gamers own knowledge of what is consider a good and bad game. Either way it seems that some no name websites and critics find it perfectly acceptable to turn in bad reviews to get views on their sites.
Nice trolling!! Why would any rational gamer support a half ass product nice try but that's not the reason this game has not sold as well.
How do you grade master pieces? The tone of both games is very different even though U4 was definitely influenced by TLOUS. I might give a slight edge to TLOUS only because of the story just carries so much weight and ending is one of the best in any game.
QB and Remedy are not trash but they most certainly are not on ND level.
Some people are just finding ways to hate on Uncharted 4, the visuals are distracting. The online is not as good as COD some people will never be satisfied no matter what a game offers.
Trash articles trying to hard to get clicks don't bother reading the article it's just the same BS.
I just finished the game and it's a must play for any gamer. If you are an Uncharted fan you won't be disappointed by far it is an experience you have to play. That a side metacritic is full of BS the game deserves all the praise it's getting un less your a fanboy or just don't like good games your going to hate on it.
@game4funz
What the hell are you ranting about of course a game has to be fun, but when reviewing games your not always going to review the types of games that you love. Anyway I will continue to enjoy and have FUN playing U4. Fanboy logic makes even less sense.
@ Stonewall
So a mediocre game like Evolve get's a higher score than U4 and your telling me that IGN's review process isn't suspect. Whatever man it's your opinion and if you think that U4 sucks that's fine by me but their such a thing as consensus meaning a vast majority disagree with IGN's initial review in progress take. Which brings up the question why give a score to a review in progress to begin with? Oh wait it wasn't intended to be click ...
IGN or any website or critic can give U4 whatever score they want but that doesn't change the popular opinion that this game is a 9 or 10 for a lot of people that have actually played it. I would give a 10 out 10 because the visual and story telling is are above average and they have set the bar for games this year.
Good for you I guess PS4 owners are not hurting for games and never have it's only fanboys that have tunnel vision that don't seem to understand. By the way notice that all the games you mentioned are third party games a side from gears.
No quality is quality regardless of the genre, in fact you don't have to like a game to appreciate that is well made even if it is not be your cup of tea that is what being objective is.
@Free_Fro
Your comment comes off a bit desinginuous but whatever, many games are coming out this year and U4 has set the bar high in terms of exclusives this year. So until another game comes out to challenge it U4 will be king.
Simple your loss bro the game is amazing and I would love to see a new Crash Bandicoot to but seeing what ND has done with U4 and the Last of Us has me excited to see what great new idea they come up with next. Sci-fi, horror, War you name it I would love to see their take on any of these genres.
IGN has no stones if they did they would have stuck with their initial review this just proves they did it to create traffic to their site by creating controversy anyway buy U4 it's awesome must play for PS4 owners.
Down grade or not it's still the best looking game on consoles that's actually a game and not some cinematic simulator.
These comparisons are kind of silly people are entitled to their opinion but if you have PS3, PS4 and the VITA then the dollar amount per game weather it's an indy game or not is far greater than not. I pay for the AAA games I really want everything else I buy at a discount and get awesome deals by being patient sure I don't get to play some AAA games at launch but so what as long as you get to play them.
Opinions opinions I could care less what IGN gives U4 why because I will be the judge of that. So far U4 has gotten many favorable reviews across the board so unless they are all wrong I will play the game and see for myself I don't need some critic or website to tell me what I should like.
It's ok to have an opinion but when you said walking simulator you lost all creditability I highly doubt you have played the game if you believe that. Troll harder next time.