Can you please explain why you disagree with the score and why you didn't like the review? Any constructive criticism is helpful. Also, have you played the game yet? It's hard to compare a game and review when you haven't played it yet.
That's exactly my thought too. I was a Halo fan and interested in the beta, but then I checked out Crackdown more and was excited for Crackdown alone. While waiting for the beta, I played Crackdown and at the time, maybe it was the fact that it was my first 360 game, I loved it. Even today I still enjoy going back into it and messing around Pacific City. Playing Crackdown 2 gave me that same sense of enjoyment but for some reason felt like inFamous.
That's good to hear that those that like Prince of Persia will like this game. I was excited to hear a new PoP game coming out and then the release of the movie made it seem like it wouldn't be as good, but they assured us it was separate game. So again, that's good to hear as I was a fan of that Prince of Persia and will have to pick this one up now.
What people don't understand is that Microsoft hides these things on the Marketplace all the time, you just have to look. Since Rare is working on Kinect, Viva Pinata is a Rare game and it is an old game they decided to put it under this game. If you think it's fake, follow the link. You can even download the beta but it won't let you play because you need a Kinect dashboard update which is only available to Kinect Beta users.