At first, I saw your score, and thought "Flame bait", but, it sounds like you genuinely tried to enjoy the game, and were legitimately disappointed.
I think your perspective is from more of an 'Action" gamer's perspective, however, as there are a lot of gamers that live for the slow, evolving game that takes a serious time investment to really appreciate.
RDR is definitely an RPG when it comes to pace and story, while the action is a bi...
I liked this review because it seems like he's a "normal" guy who's not tying to BS everyone and pretend he's a "videogame journalist" (possibly the most laughable job title ever). I'm sick of this attitude that we are obligated to "give the game a chance". If I pay for something, and I don't like it (food, clothes, movies, cars, games etc.) It's my right to voice that opinion and/or get compensated for it.
Everyone has a differe...