I think that the reason for such hate are gaming cites (like gametrailers) and their stupid comparations! I really dont know how someone can choose console because of a few better textures or warmer colours! I have bought PS3, because I have PS1 and PS2 and I love games like GT, MGS, Ratchet, ..., but I would really like to have X360 too! It has fantastic games, and no true gamer can deny that!
I could never choose only one favourite game! So I made a list!
Platformer - Okami, Ico, Shadow of the Colossuss, Jack&Dexter, Ratchet
Action/hack and slash - MGS, God of War 1&2, Devil May Cry 1
Driving - GT 3&4, ColinMcRae
Sports - Winning Eleven
Fighting - Tekken 5, Soul Calibur 3
Third person shooter - Uncharted, Resident evil 4
FPS - Resistance