Well, this is one of my favourite 'modern' game. I think this game has a great story, gameplay and visuals. The storytelling is cinematographic and fantastic. Sometimes I don't know what wrong with people, why some great games are not success.
To me, it's one of the best games of its generation, alongside with Heavenly Sword and Gears of Wars (yes, I do like it, I think it has personality, as Enslaved has).
:)
I think the only chance Sonic has to get a good game is to get a 2D game. Why Rayman can have it and Sonic doesn't?
This Sonic' 3D bullshit streak is never going to end? This game is just "fancy visual", poor gameplay.
I sincerely expected more.