I think that at least half of comments here are overrated in one way or another -- it's no use to argue if some games get more attention or better reviews in media (whether deserved or not) but ppl still are in for that fight every day.
What use it is to accuse some games being overrated when you already know that "a lot of rabid fanboys are just itching to stab me in the eye after reading this list." ??
No diablo 3 on list..? I guess it doesnt arrive b4 2013 or everyone has forgotten it since skyrim launch is coming closer day by day. :P