Am I the only one who doesn't understand all the shit-talking about Kinect? Sure, they haven't really announced any good games for it, but at least it's somewhat innovative, unlike Sony who just blatantly ripped off the Wii.
Put a shiny light up ball at the end of the controller and claim "one to one motion" and everyone goes wild over something that's been in peoples' living rooms for 4 years.
it could be that they only included games that were announced first at e3
werent games like gt5 and portal announced a while ago?
just a thought
I totally agree with the list, I'm just not sure about the rankings. Relic at #3? Homeworld isn't THAT good.