I've never actually played Thief, but I have heard a lot about Shalebridge Cradle, I'll have to check it out.
This review is for the PS3 version. It seems that the Xbox 360 and PC versions are much more polished. Sadly, on the PS3 the game is horrible.
I completely forgot about the first two. Though to be honest I spent ages trying my best to repress the mannequin scene haha.