50°

EA CEO: Motion Controls Will Not Replace Traditional Controllers

Back in 2009 when the Wii was still insanely popular and Microsoft's Kinect concept (then called Natal) was first revealed, IndustryGamers wrote that game makers would be wise not to get too caught up in the motion craze. Now it's 2011 and both Microsoft and Sony have been selling their motion solutions for the last few months. Will the industry ultimately place too much emphasis on motion controls? EA CEO John Riccitiello doesn't think so, since motion gaming seems to be limited to certain genres.

Read Full Story >>
industrygamers.com
donniebaseball5592d ago

He's right. I hope he's right at least. Motion controls for action adventure games, for FPS and a whole bunch of genres will just be too annoying.

Agent-865592d ago

I agree and here's a great quote from the article: "It’s really hard to imagine that I’m going to play a future edition of Medal of Honor, or Call of Duty, or Battlefield, hiding behind my couch, making a gun out of my finger. I’ve tried driving with gesture-based controls; I don’t really like it."

My thoughts exactly. Gesture-based controls are just too inaccurate for core games. That's why I stick with my controller for console games and keyboard/mouse for my PC gaming (plus the occasional peripheral like a racing wheel for racing games).

donniebaseball5592d ago

Funny he says he doesn't like driving games on Kinect since Burnout Paradise (an EA game) was modified as one of the first to show off Kinect.

Bigpappy5592d ago

I have been saying this for the longest. M$ actually has the right approach. Motion controls like Kinect Move or Wii should not be used to replace the controller in controller based games. That will always fail. I used to hate it when I play a PC port and they just make the controller work like keys on a Keyboard.

Kinect games are doing well because they have been built from the ground up to work only with Kinect in mind. As a result the games have a new feel to them that you can not get with a controller.

GWAVE5591d ago

Even though I do love me some motion controls, I'll always be playing the bulk of my games with a standard controller. "If it ain't broke, don't fix it" is my policy, and I don't see why controllers aren't sufficient. Heck, I've played FPSs on PC with the same WASD setup since the mid-90s and I see no reason for adjustment.

matey5591d ago

Kinect and Move are too laggy yes and only do 30fps wiimote IR has already proven it self with the hardcore gamer in fps games already so trying to tie the wii with the same brush as those add ons isnt realistic as Activision/sega/Nintendo/Retro studios with Metroid 3/Black ops,Nascar 11,Goldeneye 007/Conduit,Conduit 2,Grinder ect all have proven to be more realistic and accurate than standard controls oh the wii can do 60fps in fps games using 1on1 IR

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 5591d ago
btk5591d ago

Wrong matey. Move is not laggy. You must be thinking of Kinect.

MintBerryCrunch5592d ago

Captain Hindsight told me this a long time ago....nothing new guys

Agent-865592d ago

And I believe Captain Hindsight found out from Captain Obvious.

MintBerryCrunch5592d ago

well my work here is done

*flies away*

Spinal5591d ago

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL

Captain Hindsight and Captain Obvious... ahhh where would I be without my heroes =)

TheLeprachaun5591d ago

I hope the coon rapes you MintBerryCrunch.

Vesemir5592d ago (Edited 5592d ago )

Amen to that. Die already motion crap. Go back to hell and stay there forever.

Calm Down Sunshine5591d ago

Perhaps they can take 3D with them as well, or has the backlash not started for that yet?

Give it time.

Incipio5592d ago (Edited 5592d ago )

Unless motion controller latency is effectively eliminated somehow, then motion controls will forever be an afterthought in action, FPS or anything faster or more involved than casual sports or walking your character around.

matey5591d ago

if ur talking Kinect/Move yes leave the wiimote out of this as that is 1on1 with anything that invovles IR pointing zero lag as in all reviews the devise has no lag only the games have the lag in wiimote IR as games like Metroid corruption have proved 60fps zero lag and just simply amazing controls u cant get out of anologue

blackburn55592d ago (Edited 5592d ago )

Please. Your just repeating what Sony said. They said the same thing when they revealed the Move, and Microsoft and now EA are repeating exactly what they said. Copy cats. @ Incipio. play SC with Move. No noticable lag or latency. Don't listen to the liars who say their is lag.

Show all comments (38)
50°

EA Lays Off Staff Across All Battlefield Studios Following Record-Breaking Battlefield 6 Launch

EA is laying off an unknown number of individuals from across its Battlefield teams, including workers at Criterion, Dice, Ripple Effect, and Motive Studios, IGN understands.

49d ago Replies(1)
peppeaccardo48d ago

When logic meets EA it generates anti-matter ..... so try not to apply it in any meaningful way. Entropy is what matters in there !!

badz14947d ago

cue the apologist saying that these are mostly just contractors hired for this specific project bla bla bla

HyperMoused47d ago

TTK for BF employees needs adjusting

50°

EA makes layoffs at Skate developer Full Circle

The free-to-play reboot topped 15 million players in under three weeks, but EA now claims it needs to reshape the development team.

Read Full Story >>
gamedeveloper.com
Profchaos59d ago

The community warned them this would happen but nope they knew better they continued with the live service push the made the art style cartoonish and this is the result

isarai_lee59d ago

It's always so bizarre when studios announce something super early in development under the suggestion of forming the game to player feedback, and then they push against all feedback heading straight for the cliff while everyone is warning them along the way

badboyz0959d ago (Edited 59d ago )

🤣🤣🤣

50°

US Lawmakers Urge Review Of EA Sale

The Congressional Labor Caucus sent a letter to the FTC warning the debt-financed, largely PIF-owned deal could be bad news for workers

Read Full Story >>
aftermath.site
Trilithon94d ago

lol ya think? they're sending all that work to the cheaper labor market as soon as possible. and FYI, that labor market has exploded in the last 5-10 years. They have enough people to replace every single job. But honestly, EA is over filled with useless upper management as it is. You could probably trim 25% of their staff with no real loss in production. They aren't gamers, they're business execs. Just look at how many AI related jobs they're already starting to post. Its also hilarious that PIF owns Battle field 6

lodossrage94d ago (Edited 94d ago )

Wait,

The same congress that attacked Lina Khan when she fought the Microsoft Activision purchase.
The same congress that allowed Disney to buy 90% of Fox
The same congress that allowed Liv Golf to buy the PGA
The same congress that sits back while Paramount tries a hostile takeover despite losing the bid for Warner Bros.

NOW, the suddenly cares about doing what's "right" for works? Yeah, right.

thorstein94d ago

No. There were elections and some of the scum were replaced.

TheColbertinator93d ago

Different elections. Different scum. Same results.

rlow193d ago

i know its a long shot, but i hope this gets shot down.

ZwVw93d ago

EA now owned by The Saudis and Ubisoft to inevitably be owned by China. In hindsight, once EA and Ubisoft started having their financial woes, they should have pulled a Koei Tecmo/Bandai Namco by merging their operations into one.