Sequels Should Be Banned

Montrealien6246d ago (Edited 6246d ago )

I agree, and most do. As long as it pushes the original concept and delivers some good story progression.

kharma456246d ago

I too love a good sequel.

Without sequels, no KOTOR II, Gears 2, KZ2, MGS 2-4 (and Portable Ops), no more GTA games.

chrisjc6246d ago

Great article. It would be sad to see a lot of sequels go, but we'd most likely get more original games. Imagine if instead of Ninja Gaiden 2 we got a re-worked Ninja game with Ayane. It would have felt more fresh.

Reply Agree 0 Disagree 2

Firstkn1ghT6246d ago

Uuuuum that would just plain suck.

kaironn6246d ago

some sequels are good, some are terrible.

Reply Agree 4 Disagree 0

dalibor6246d ago (Edited 6246d ago )

Def. agree. I don't know about you guys but back in the day I remember being glad that Crash Bandicoot 2, Twisted Metal 2, Resident Evil 2 & Tekken 2 were released to name a few. H*ll even 2xtreme was better than the first. That was so long ago haha.

Reply Agree 1 Disagree 1

HDgamer6246d ago

Some new IP's need to go then.

Reply Agree 4 Disagree 0

morganfell6246d ago

That's right, it's not a misprint. I genuinely believe that the gaming world would be better off without gamerlimit.com

Reply Agree 7 Disagree 2

buckethead_9116246d ago (Edited 6246d ago )

Sequels Should Be Banned....Ok.

If that was the case, we would miss out on epic games like these I guess?

Half Life 2 and the episodes.
Gears of War 2
Uncharted 2
God of War 2 & 3
Halo 2 & 3

Ouch.

Reply Agree 4 Disagree 1

chrisjc6246d ago

"sequels aren't necessarily a bad thing, but they are becoming too much of the focus."

That's what I gathered from the article. The writing made it seem like "banned" is a joke; and that a lot of sequels are in fact good.

But of course this is N4G - people don't read the articles.

Rich16316246d ago (Edited 6246d ago )

Just GTFO! CoD4, MGS4, Resistance 2, Gears of War 2, Half-Life 2, or Halo 2. All of those were better than the originals, sure some sequels suck but COME ON! Those are shinning examples about how to evolve the game and improve already great mechanics.

Reply Agree 0 Disagree 2

Spydiggity6246d ago

resistance 2, halo 2, and gears of war 2 were NOT better than the originals. and call of duty 2-5 are all pretty much the same thing.

and the point of the article, i think, is to make us realize that we're missing out on potentially great new ideas and IPs because companies know the money is in making sequels.

sequels aren't necessarily a bad thing, but they are becoming too much of the focus.

Reply Agree 2 Disagree 2

Socomer 19796246d ago

do you guys even have jobs?
sequels make jobs.
can you hatch a new game idea every week?
no.
did you even play every game that has been released.
not making sequels ends the business.

Reply Agree 2 Disagree 1

ia_studio6245d ago

I recently made 500 game ideas, and deleted 476, in a 2 WEEK marathon, of course they're web game ideas i'm a flash game developer.
my point is you can make a good game idea every week you just need to be creative.

Aclay6246d ago (Edited 6246d ago )

Sequels souldn't be banned, that's just ridicolous.

If Video Game sequels should be banned, then I guess this guy thinks Movie Sequels should be banned too? I don't know about anyone else, but I'm looking forward to the sequels Transformers Revenge of the Fallen, Terminator Salvation and a bunch of other movie sequels.

It takes a LOT of money and time too invest in a Brand new IP... if there were no sequels to video games at all, more than likely there would be only a handful of games released every year.

Just look at Team ICO for an example... to this day they haven't made a single sequel yet, but since 2001, they've only released 2 games. Developing new games that aren't sequels takes a TON of time and I don't think this guy realizes it.

DMasta7186246d ago

Well I'm sorry if the game is so good that I want to see more of that said game.

Reply Agree 2 Disagree 0

yog-sothot6246d ago

imo, some games are made to have sequels, others not...

look at Uncharted for example, Nathan is a treasure hunter, he lives many adventures, that's obvious. The game is awesome and as there is room for many improvements, it's perfectly logical.

On the other hand, let's take Okami or Bioshock, those are great games too, but do they need sequels ? Not sure... Unfortunately, it's only business that drives sequels development. Okami would have had one if the first game had been succesfull. Bioshock will have one and I must say I'm quite afraid

Unicron6246d ago

What a tool. Like anything in life, it's about BALANCE. I'm sorry, but gaming would NOT be better off without MGS, Pokemon, Halo, and Mario sequels. A quality sequel can be just as innovative and original as a new IP. Sequels do not stifle creativity any more than new IPs do.

Reply Agree 1 Disagree 1

Socomer 19796246d ago

he just limited his hits.

Reply Agree 2 Disagree 1

NMC20076246d ago

N4G = N4H = News4Hits, change the name stat.

This article and writer of said article are absolute horsesh1t.
-_-

Reply Agree 2 Disagree 0

Andrew Wiggin6246d ago

I disagree, and one of your points is moot. Shadow of the Colossus is a sequel to Ico (though the timeline is different).

Reply Agree 1 Disagree 1

kaironn6246d ago

I think someone doesn't understand what a spin-off is; it's not a sequel.

lsujester6246d ago

Technically, it's a prequel. Remember, in the end Wanderer sires the line of horned boys to which Ico belongs.

kaironn6246d ago

Fumito Ueda: "I didn’t intend the boy to be the same as in ICO. Yes, users have thought that Shadow of the Colossus is a prequel to ICO. I wanted to make it so the imagination is up to the user."

So apparently imagination is canon now?

lsujester6246d ago (Edited 6246d ago )

And he later admitted that they were.

http://www.wired.com/scienc...

Wired News: Is there any connection between the worlds of Ico and Shadow of the Colossus?

Fumito Ueda: There's no specific connection as far as a timeline. But, both games exist in the same world.

WN: But you've said the baby we see at the end of Colossus is the first "baby born with horns" referred to in the backstory of Ico.

FU: Yes. I wanted to give some idea to the player, after you complete the game, that there was a connection to Ico. That's why I put in the baby with the horns. If somebody goes all the way through the game, I wanted them to be rewarded.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 6246d ago

JohnnyMann4206246d ago (Edited 6246d ago )

I TOTALLY hated the following games:

Super Metroid
Super Mario World
GTA: San Andreas
Castlevania SoTN
Metal Gear 4
Baldur's Gate II
COD 4
Street Fighter 2, 3 and 4
Diablo 2 (III should be banned...rofl )
Final Fantasy VII
Mortal Kombat II
Resident Evil 4
Saints Row 2
Ninja Gaiden II (NES)
Tekken 3
Tony Hawk 2
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
..And others I surely forgot...

Yeah... these games are in NO WAY some of the best games I have ever played or remembered. I don't believe they helped shaped some of the games we play. None of these have some of the most memorable story lines. None of them were so fun to keep me up for hours on end. None of them were the example on the way a system should work or how a game should be played. None of them have a fan following for a good reason.

What a completely retarded article.

I understand what he is trying to get at, but he fails.

Perhaps we should be given different electric outlets in each state since the standardization of the electrical outlet has prevented a better one from being invented?

In that case... perhaps there should be 20,0000 computer OS to choose from rather than a few.

Perhaps I will make bread tomorrow with rocks and birdsh*t?

Innovation and creativity is great, but I think the article is pessimistic, stupid and also short sighted.

Gamers wont buy sh*t just because it has the number 3 at the end.

Well... maybe if Sh*t 1 and Sh*t 2 were good...

Reply Agree 1 Disagree 2

kaironn6246d ago

Did you read it?

The author praises Final Fantasy in the article.

CrazyOrange6246d ago

we wouldn't be got MGS4, halo 3,gears 2 and other sequels.

OhMyGandhi6246d ago

Good developers usually know to quit.
And if they are raking in the cash, have fun trying to convince them to stop "Halo 5" or "Resident Evil 7", hell even "Final Fantasy" has a crapload of sequals to boot.

Truth is, if the original game had flaws, the sequel allows the developer to work on it, and improve their game.

Sequels are good. And necessary.
Period.

kaironn6246d ago

Once again, the author praises Final Fantasy in the article.

I have a lot of faith in the N4G audience.

Reply Agree 2 Disagree 0

Cloud-14096246d ago

We must not have alot of good developers then. Games like Grim Fandango, Psychonauts, and Killer 7 are all superior to 75%+ of the sequels released these days. Gamers get so much of the same nowadays they completely ignore anything that isn't *insert game name here and add a number on the end*, and I know Killer 7 has 7 at the end.

otherZinc6246d ago

needs to be banned from talking about games, now I know to avoid gamerlimit.com

There are many stories to be told within the Halo Universe & they are getting to it. Halo Wars & Halo 3:ODST is the start, I cant wait!

Just think of the games we'd miss since Donkey Kong in 1982.

C. Rossi is a clown & so is his site.

Reply Agree 0 Disagree 2

chrisjc6246d ago

What a grown up way to handle things :D

Let's take one writer's (of many) opinion and apply it towards an entire site.

Cloud-14096246d ago

First off it's not "my" site. Secondly I can see why you only have one bubble. I love how you picked out Halo, truth be told I love getting you Halo fanboys all riled up because you defend it so strongly, even though deep down you know it's not that revolutionary.

Seeing as you picked out Halo, and the display picture is one of Master Chief, I am going to assume you didn't read the article, and only look at the pretty pictures to make your assumption you illiterate moron.
I'm not flaming Microsoft in the article, I cover all 3 major systems.

willjoea6246d ago

No sequels ??? Are ya kidding me ? You mean no Resident Evil 2, God of War 2, Halo 2, Gears of War 2. No Final Fantasy 2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11, oh you get the idea. Sometimes developers don't hit there stride in an ip until the second or even third outing. I couldn't imagine gaming WITHOUT sequels...

Cloud-14096246d ago

Another person who clearly hasnt read the article properly, or at all.

Fullish6246d ago

haha, gotta love commenters who don't read the article.

willjoea6246d ago

Actually, not only did I read the article in its' entirety but was actually able to comprehend its content. And despite the fact that the author contradicted himself on several points, the gist of the article was that game developers should be concentrating on new ips rather than revisiting existing games. My inclusion of the Final Fantasy series in my comment was to point out that although they are all different, they ARE sequels, even though the author seems to see it differently.

PS: I can also walk and chew gum at the same time. Go figure ;)

Cloud-14096246d ago

Actually in the article i said that Fantasy did sequels right. I never said they werent sequels.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 6246d ago

Homicide6246d ago

It depends on the game. Games like MGS, Resident Evil and Xenosaga, it's appropriate to have a sequel to tell the story. It would be pretty boring if the sequel remains the same like the writer puts it: same gameplay, a few new things and updated graphics. That's why I appreciated Resident Evil 4 and Persona 3. They changed the series. Sequels need to change it up to make it interesting.

FFX-2, let's face it. This should of never been made. FFX was epic by itself. The story is great and had a nice conclusion. Why ruin it with this POS FFX-2? Same with KH2. The ending is great, and I don't think there should be a sequel for that game.

XLiveGamer6246d ago

C.Rossi of Gamer Limit Writes: "That's right, it's not a misprint.
I genuinely believe that the gaming world would be better off without sequels.

---------

Xavier Livegamer on N4G Writes: "That's right, it's not a misprint.
I genuinely believe that the Movies world would be better off without sequels.

Wakka_6246d ago

my game has the worst sequel, ya?

whitefang19886246d ago

this guys nuts no sequels means no fnial fantasy no half life 2 No GTA
so what does he think of movies then should Lord of the rings just stoped after the 1st one?

idiot

chrisjc6246d ago

3 comments people have above on how "the poster praises Final Fantasy in the article", and you still post "the writer says no Final Fantasy?"

Also, LOTR was a book trilogy before it was a movie. Books tend to be a bit different in that they need to spent a great deal of time describing events to you, and that wouldn't be feasible in one book (tome). Of course they needed to make LOTR 2 and 3 into movies; it was an established trilogy. Comparing books to video games doesn't make sense.