Console Creatures writes, "Reanimal is both beautiful and horrifying, carving out a unique identity for the studio. The blend of co-op mechanics and atmospheric storytelling mixed with nightmarish creature design creates an experience you won't soon forget. Despite playing solo, I enjoyed my time with Reanimal but felt I would've appreciated the gameplay much more with someone I know to help me navigate the island. Ultimately, Tarsier's penchant for telling bone-chilling horror stories is why they continue to make a lasting impression."
"Reanimal is unsettling, oppressive and sometimes shocking, yet masterfully crafted - a game that trusts you to interpret its horrors and draw your own conclusions."
- Stuart Cullen, TechStomper
VGChartz's Lee Mehr: "Like its many horrifying creatures, REANIMAL feels both gargantuan and wobbly. It wouldn't be ridiculous to claim Tarsier currently holds the presentation crown for this particular type of atmospheric puzzle-platformer. But in its quest to reach those empyrean heights, certain fundamentals were occasionally discarded. Some may say certain faults are endemic for these types of games, but that would discount even some of Tarsier's previous work as well. Its pursuit of branching away from the past reaches something of a mixed conclusion – though appreciated all the same."
Wow, well I haven't played it or watched a bunch of videos, because I don't want to ruin the game. Horror games I want all surprises and scares intact! 6.5 seems pretty harsh compared to other very reputable reviewers. Definitely going to play it at some point.
I mean, if you're a fan of Tarsier's Little Nightmares games it's certainly worth a shot. I'm, certainly toward the lower-end of the review spectrum, but I should emphasize it's still decent, a tentative recommendation for these types of fans (though the $40 price point isn't fun to swallow). There's just something about its annoying mechanical missteps that cause it to stumble. For comparison's sake: I place Little Nightmares (1) at an 8/10 rating back in the day.
"Reanimal, announced back in August 2024, is finally out. It comes from the creators of Little Nightmares 1 & 2, and has us stepping into a dark, depressing world. I’ve had my eyes on this game since it was shown, and I am happy to be reviewing it." Kyle @ Thumb Culture
Out now on one of those Nintendo Switch 2 keycards.