Innoxent

@Cluclap

Who said I removed my brain. Not overanalyzing either it's only quite obvious. She also barely had any scenes and she doesn't amount to anything at the end so yes...waste of character and unrealistically portrayed. I didn't find the fights with her engaging at all...definitely turned my brain off for that since you lose no matter what you do...spam square.

@shadow

I said combat experienced climbers...you must not h...

@foxtrot

I whole heartedly agree with you. I did find it odd that very few mentioned this restriction.

Seriously??
That's kind a funny. Can they do that?

It's barely a thing. It's there...and there is a line that throws the word bigot out there like an ignorant child would but otherwise it's fine.

Leaks are true but the severity of them aren't really there. At least not so far for me.

@Geo

I certainly hope you don't get banned. Insults are flying both ways so if you get banned do should anyone who has thrown a swing at the other side.

Your entitled to your opinion like everyone else.

Well there's a lot of 0s and 10s given out by people who either had not played or did not finish the game so in both cases it's just dumb.

Obviously I don't think a 0 should even be allowed in the review scale...that's what 1 is for 0 is the lack of a score .

Somewhere I read someone say that all the good in the game outweighed the bad and therefore it still managed a 10/10. In that same logic, for someone else all the bad outweighed the g...

Well that's bull. The 1st was epic and awesome...in fact I'm going to replay it soon.

I'm on the side of free opinions with the second game but I'm quite tired of all these articles. Enjoy the game or don't. Nobody needs to approve your decision on it. If it's a zero for the ou so be it, if a ten so be it.

How was she great?
She was the most unrealistic character in the uncharteds.

I don't care the military training you have. She was very skinny and could take down two combat experienced buff climbers. Climbing like in uncharted is unrealistic but would require an enormous amount of strength and endurance.

1on1 was believable but 2 on 1 not so much. Is especially to the degree that she beats them.

Except!

Last of us 1 spoilers below*

Joel only killed on his way out of the hospital because the fireflies wanted to take her brain out. Killing her in the process.
They omit the reality of the situation so therefore it is not the same at all.
So in that regard I would say the message failed to deliver correctly.
Abby ok the other hand is monstrous. Takes a special kind of person to brutally beat another with a golf club and a desir...

It prevented the discussion of the latter half of the game which therefore prevented a proper review of the game.

You couldn't write about it or talk about it so the written review and score would be disjointed.

The trailers did give the impression that you and Joel go off an an adventure but other than that this other stuff is silly.

And you could say other gamers are using the journalist reviews as fuel to say the game is a masterpiece before completing as well. Or does this only go one way?

The majority of legit negative reviews agree with this sentiment. Story is a big part of the last of us. Many don't like it.
Many do like it.

Shouldn't disregard the ones you disagree with or claim that they're somehow being childish. Many here can't stand that there are negative simply because they themselves are enjoying it. Doesn't make sense in their brains.

Agree to disagree is the motto. But that's rarely effective. ...

YouTubers and smaller channels are less likely to be corrupt in my opinion. Many barely make a living off YouTube and have to work a separate job. They are less likely to shill or be swayed by mass media and political correctness to like or dislike something.

All the people replying to your comment haven't finished the game and yet are calling it a masterpiece....I sense a lot of hypocrisy here. Weren't we complaining about the same for those user reviews?

I have no issue with it but people here did. So im seeing some inconsistencies.

I don't like chocolate cake.
There must be something wrong with me ...maybe I'm a chocophobe or something. Lol

With that thinking then the 10s are also not logical correct? Don't only focus in the negative reviews let's also look at the positive ones given out around the same time as the bad ones. All illogical! Right?

Let's give journalists all the power to review...good idea.

I would say now nothing. You like the game. Good on you. Others don't so now what?

But you do get the story experience. For many that is enough. Especially those disappointed with the spoilers and wanted to make sure not to support the weird decisions they made a few hours into the game.