HonestDragon

SuperContributor
CRank: 7Score: 43650

An Open Letter to Gaming Media

I have been on the sidelines observing the recent stories that involve everything from Anita Sarkeesian to Zoe Quinn to Phil Fish to Polygon to Kotaku to indie studios' attacks to corruption and finally to gaming media lashing out at gamers. I have recently commented that enough is enough and I'm not going to stand for it anymore. Everything that I have mentioned is going to get their fair share of my open dialogue concerning their individual strikes within the gaming community and at gamers. They have taken free punches at us without consequence. Anytime they are challenged, we get silenced and are left with having to let our voices be heard in a miniscule scale on random forums or comments sections. That is given that you don't get banned or censored. Not today, folks. Today, I'm opening up this series of blogs with an open letter to the very gaming media who have attacked gamers and why their attempts at misdirection is a poor effort that bore no success.

I can only really begin my opening statement with one direct question: What the hell are you self-proclaimed journalists doing? You sit at your computer screens and act all high and mighty, while belittling the dignity of the gaming industry with your convoluted and misguided notions of supremacy over everyone else. Case in point with this very situation regarding the relationship between gaming media and game developers, you are confronted about this story, yet you resist it and point fingers at us to proclaim that we are the problem. You sit there and attack gamers (the very people who help you keep a job mind you) and say that we are the problem? We are the problem for actions that you have done? We are responsible for the very real corruption going on in game journalism? Correct me if I'm wrong, but we are not the ones giving artificial praise to projects done by someone who voluntarily slept with us and we are not the ones accepting perks and bribes from publishers and public relations.

When someone has the gall to declare that an entire group of people is a problem, it speaks of both ignorance and megalomania. That person is so willingly blind that they do everything in their power to make others out to be the bad guys. When someone does this, they more often than not do it because they did something wrong. They are either in sheer denial and convince themselves that everyone else is the problem or they realize they are busted and attempt to use a scapegoat. Their attempts at reverse psychology is an effort to reduce the negative aspect of their actions, while reflecting an entirely different subject unto another party. In this case, when gamers unleashed their frustration with the recent corruption that was made public, the reverse argument made by you journalists is that the reason gamers are so angry is because we are misogynists.

Do any of you "journalists" who started that conversation honestly think that we are going to allow you to label us like that? Don't get me wrong, I'm not ignorant to the fact that there is sexism in the world. I've seen it firsthand. But what you "journalists" are essentially doing here is defining all gamers (including female gamers) under one of the many stigmas that we have been fighting against for years. People who have agendas (like Anita Sarkeesian, Jack Thompson, and Phil Fish) have been trying to convince anyone who will listen that people in the video game industry and gamers are testosterone-filled, misogynistic, disrespectful, violent brutes who don't deserve the things we have access to lest we end up disrupting the fabric of society. You "journalists" have successfully joined their ranks.

How can you conceive the idea that by reversing the polarity of the topic at hand (which is supposed to be about Zoe Quinn influencing game media via sexual favors or any other recent corruption for that matter) that it will result in you gaining favor? The topic is Zoe Quinn is accused of sleeping with a few journalists in exchange for positive coverage of her game. The rebuttal on your side? Gamers are overreacting and angry over nothing because we are misogynists. Seriously?! You just really wanted to commit career suicide there, huh? There is a plethora of information available that pertains to Zoe Quinn and her storied history, yet you have not proven or disproven your involvement and instead opted to attack gamers. You are actively avoiding the topic that started all of this and that makes us even more skeptical of you!

Your job is to report on the recent news of the video game industry. Images, gameplay videos, first looks, trailers, interviews, conferences, reviews, and many other topics that could be worked on via your outlet is what you should be doing; however, giving your opinion like it's law seems to be the going trend for some of you. Sharing your opinion is all good and well, but lately that seems to be the only thing you are doing. Attacking gamers seems to be the next best thing for you as well.

The ultimate problem that lies here is that you have no idea how to conduct yourselves publicly. You are already coming up from a high horse that you put yourselves on. Naturally, your egoism will show as we have seen countless times. When you write on the internet, that's technically public domain space, but on a worldwide scale. When you attack someone over Twitter, that is seen by hundreds of thousands of people. When you review a game and dock it by a whole point by bringing up a topic that is so insignificant to the game itself, that can be seen by everyone. When you lash out against gamers and tell them that they should be grateful to you for your contributions, people will see that. When you misrepresent an entire industry and its audience to bring up selective points to support your claims, you will have backlash. You have no one to blame but yourselves. You are creating your own hell. We have zero influence for what comes out of your mouth. If you cannot filter out what may get you into trouble, then that fault is your own.

You have prided yourselves as these great pioneers for writing in the video game industry, yet you have failed your audience. You failed because you accepted favors and gifts. You failed because you attacked the very audience who keeps you in business. You failed because any shred of dignity that you had is left to be questioned. Rather, you left that dignity at the door when you made the conscious decision to take whatever perk was offered to you. No one in the community can go by your word because of your failures.

I'm not ignorant nor is the majority of the gaming community. We are not stupid. We are not the fools that you think that we are. We do have bad apples here and there (as does every community in existence), but you single them out as the voice for all. We know there is corruption in the gaming industry. Whether you're on Youtube or any major gaming publication site, some of your peers have been offered something. If it comes to light that everything regarding Zoe Quinn is true (because barely anything involving her has been undeniably proven as fact given it's difficult to find any information), then every single journalist who attacked gamers through the pieces that I have linked here have lost all credibility.

http://kotaku.com/we-might-...

http://dangolding.tumblr.co...

http://arstechnica.com/gami...

http://www.gamasutra.com/vi...

Why? Because the yearly abuse that the gaming press does to the community at large is constant. They write that gamers are entitled, immature, and recently misogynists. There are multiple articles from journalists that detail how gamers are horrible people, yet gamers are the ones who help them have a job. Again, brilliant idea on their part by insulting the very audience to which is the only audience who can support them. Simply put, shame on you. Shame on you for letting go of your dignity and professionalism. Shame on you for turning your back on the very people who support you. Shame on you for plaguing gaming media with your sensationalist articles and hidden agendas.

I don't want this open letter to be misinterpreted. I'm not targeting every single writer out there. There are good people in the gaming media. Just like how we (the gamers) refuse a few bad apples to ruin our image, the same goes for those people in gaming media. There are good writers and workers in gaming media that work their fingers to the bone to help you be informed and entertained. They do what they do because they love it. The perks they get from being in that part of the industry is just a bonus for them.

I'm not merely talking about the big websites, but also Youtube and smaller sites. There are people worth supporting out there. Whether they go to PAX, Tokyo Game Show, and E3 to do interviews or if they review games or if they give helpful tips and tricks for games, there are many of them worth supporting. Those people who attack gamers by saying we are misogynists and we are the problem with the industry have their heads so far up their butts that any insult they hurl at us is equal to crap. Their egos know no bounds and they flaunt their position in our face.

From this point on, should I see any article or self-proclaimed "journalist" ever make a questionable piece or attack gamers again, be on notice. I'm starting a new series. It will be called "Journalism Failure" where I will dissect the same sensationalism, propaganda, clickbait, and hidden agendas that some writers are known for. I have the article below to thank for giving me the idea that the gaming press "are becoming obsolete". Stay tuned and stay informed, N4G.

http://www.slate.com/articl...

-Foxtrot4176d ago (Edited 4176d ago )

Great article

It's a shame that this whole thing getting worse now though

I mean people who pledge certain Kickstarter money to fund goals are getting blocked/banned if they support GG. Mighty No 9 being the main culprit

https://www.facebook.com/ph...

Heads of studios are starting to be big headed and obnoxious, like Randy Pitchford recently

https://www.facebook.com/ph...

Then you have the whole 4chan thing going on where Moot basically did a 180 on the site he created just because he was brainwashed by his girlfriend...who works for Gawker.

http://i1.kym-cdn.com/photo...

More attacks continue against GamerGate supporters yet nothing is said about it.

https://www.facebook.com/ph...

Not to mention some Indie developers within the industry don't seem to get GamerGate at all. Tim Schafer for example

http://i0.kym-cdn.com/photo...

It's becoming a war zone

NewMonday4175d ago (Edited 4175d ago )

got into a twitter exchange with a bunch of these guys, they call use #gamergaters now, they truly think they are a class above, a quasi higher society.

this is all from the special treatment given to them by publishers and advertisers, and also the cult of personality they developed by gaining followers in the audience, it inevitably created entitlement and corruption.

DragonKnight4175d ago

Yeah I've been called a #gamergater by the delusional on the opposing side. Their arguments are quite hilarious to. Today one of them tried saying #GamerGate has failed because an Alexa rating they viewed showed that IGN, Kotaku, and Gamespot's viewcount didn't go down.

Oh no, we sure as hell lost didn't we? I guess we'll just stop emailing the advertisers and having sponsorships removed, forcing sites like RockPaperShotgun into begging for money on Patreon because of Alexa ratings. Dat crushing defeat of #GamerGate.

NewMonday4175d ago (Edited 4175d ago )

even if the hit's don't go down the reader trust will, Fox news still high in the ratings but most people, even conservatives, know they are watch BS most of the time.

Juste_Belmont4174d ago

Well, one way to get the message across would be to boycott/ignore those sites and developers that either don't support cleaning up this mess or are complicit in it.

I haven't visited Kotaku or any of those other sites in a long time (back when they began bashing all things Japanese, ironic considering their site is called Kotaku), Gearbox never did impress me, and although I almost donated to Mighty No. 9, I'm glad now that I didn't.

As for 4chan, I've never really heard anything good about that site, but based on what I do know about it, their own user base probably won't be too happy about someone trying to muzzle them.

DragonKnight4176d ago

Having been a part of #GamerGate from the very beginning, I can tell you that never was there a time that I can remember (with possibly the exception of the Mass Effect 3 ending controversy) where the gaming media was as hate filled and childish as the past month has shown them to be.

As if by coincidence, or cosmic irony, Bloodborne has shown us that gaming journalists are right when they refuse to call themselves gamers, but not because of the reasons they are adamant about but because they suck at games. Gaming journalists are nothing more than glorified bloggers who are content with rubbing their "journalism degree" all over their body as they type out their latest pro-SJW article about how gaming is sexist and in turn makes us all act sexist.

In fact, they remind me of these guys from South Park.

https://www.youtube.com/wat...

In fact, that one clip perfectly describes the attitude of gamers vs. gaming journalism to a frickin' tee. Randy is the gamer, the cable company is the gaming media, and they are that arrogant. Have you seen the B.S. that Leigh Alexander of Gamasutra or Ben Kuchera of who the hell cares has been saying?

He apparently didn't get enough from David Jaffe calling him on his B.S. back when Twisted Metal came out, he just had to get worse. Even going so far as to try and convince The Escapist to change their ToS to suit HIS definition harassment.

These people are a disease. They think they are necessary when the modern internet age continues to show how obsolete they actually are. When most people tend to place higher respect and value on people like Angry Joe or TotalBiscuit on Youtube, and when most people LOVE the idea of Nintendo Direct and the Treehouse segment they had at E3, these journalists should begin counting, because their days are numbered and #GamerGate took a huge chunk out of their remaining time.

https://www.youtube.com/wat...

Blacklash934176d ago (Edited 4176d ago )

"I will dissect the same sensationalism, propaganda, clickbait, and hidden agendas that some writers are known for."

You mean half of the articles posted on N4G? :P

I only wish gaming journalism involved actual journalism. Gameinformer has its game and interview exclusives and Gamasutra has its interviews, industry reports, and detailed analyses. Why can't more media outlets be more like that? A lot of the stuff here on N4G seems to be regurgitated press releases, worthless opinion articles, and convention previews; pieces that require little to no journalism skills that anyone with a computer and keyboard could write.

GenericNameHere4172d ago

Kotaku is good... If the article is written by Jason Schrier. Dude gets lots of awesome scoops on game production. If you see somebody else's name, quickly exit out of there.

RoninRaven4176d ago (Edited 4176d ago )

http://reviewtruth.com/hell...

Here's a good piece on "Gamers are Dead" delusions

LightDiego4175d ago

These journalists that act high and mighty need to understand that they are useless, click-bait articles and attacking gamers will not protect them after all the corruption.
Great open letter, and let's keep boycotting these pricks until they go away.

Show all comments (13)
20°

Bus Simulator 27 Announced for PC, PS5, and Xbox

Today, Astragon announced a new installment of the Bus Simulator franchise, simply titled Bus Simulator 27, coming for PC, PS5, and Xbox.

Read Full Story >>
simulationdaily.com
20°

MARVEL MaXimum Collection Announced For Consoles and PC

Limited Run Games, MARVEL and Konami have announced MARVEL MaXimum Collection for Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S and PC.

Read Full Story >>
nettosgameroom.com
darthv721h ago

would love it if xmen arcade offered two modes. the regular single screen 4 player mode and the ultra wide (simulated dual screen) 6 player mode.

30°

Resident Evil Requiem Graphics Comparison Shows Switch 2 vs PS5 and Xbox Series S

A new Resident Evil Requiem graphics comparison examines Switch 2, PS5, and Xbox Series S, revealing performance gaps and visual trade offs.

Read Full Story >>
twistedvoxel.com
Neonridr4h ago

interesting that the Switch 2 version renders at a higher internal resolution. I wonder if they dropped it down to the same as the Series S the game would hit the 60 mark more often than it does.

Solid port though, can't wait to play this tomorrow (or whenever my preorder gets to me lol)