All Channels
Popular
Insert Thought Provoking Quote Here

DragonKnight

Contributor
CRank: 9Score: 212030

Gaming Culture Suffers From Institutionalized Amnesia

First Scenario: The year is 198X, you're a young boy or girl who's come to know video games and love what you've experienced. You have friends that have a Nintendo Entertainment System just like you and every day after school, and on the weekends, you try to convince your parents to let you play some video games, or to go over to your friends house so you can play them there. You finished your homework, you deserve a reward, and your parents agree to your request. You have so much fun playing Super Mario Bros. 3, or Metroid, or Castlevania and you talk about it forever with your friends. Gaming is your favourite thing to do, and the thing you talk about the most.

Your discussions range from "were you able to beat that boss?" to "I found this awesome secret the other day" to "so who's your favourite character?"

You are at a pure state of gaming enjoyment. The kind of euphoria that only children can fully experience and fully comprehend. You hope this feeling lasts forever.

Scenario 2: The year is 20XX and you've been gaming for decades. You never lost that passion you had, and you made many friends because of it. You seek out different types of games, and all kinds of experiences because, hey it's what you love. But something is different. You notice that many of the friends you've had hardly talk about how fun a game is anymore. Instead they're saying that Mario makes women look weak, Resident Evil is racist, Assassin's Creed is sexist, etc...

You look around the internet to see that the discussion is now how terrible games and those who make them, or even play them, are and we should all be ashamed of ourselves and everything needs to change. You see people saying that the only way games can truly be fun is if these specific groups are represented in these specific ways and that there is one specific group that's preventing that from happening and have been the problem with gaming for 40 years.

You see people say these things under the idea that because gamers want games to be considered an artform, to be able to freely express themes and ideas that only artforms can be allowed to express, that games should be criticized in some all-encompassing "this is what this game is actually expressing to me" kind of way and that this line of thinking has made so many people invent new, politically or financially driven, narratives that have nothing to do with 40 years of electronic entertainment.

You're now an adult that has lived to see political and ideological agendas inserted into the critiquing methods of the now vastly sensationalist "enthusiast press" that covers gaming. You wonder which new bit of coverage of a game will contain some kind of message that said game is misogynist, racist, or homophobic. You grow tired of being labeled in the same way because you are a gamer. You wonder when games ceased being about the fun and instead being about how some random person feels about the representation of some group in the game. You ask yourself, always with utter bewilderment, "Doesn't anyone remember how much fun games were when we were kids? Don't people know that these games contain characters and places that aren't actually real?"

And you lament about what you see. You just wish that you could go back in time and relive that pure enjoyment again.

That is what gaming has become today. People who are easily manipulated by people who may or may not be gamers have allowed politics and social justice agendas to pollute the ecosystem of the gaming industry. People who grew up playing games, never once thinking about things like a character's outfit or fictional body proportions, never thinking about whether or not you could visit an NPC who was beaten by another NPC in a hospital, or whether or not that NPC you just murdered should have had a deep and compelling backstory for you to feel bad about afterwards, have completely forgotten how playing games with their friends when they were kids made them feel.

Nowadays we have people not viewing games as electronic entertainment, but instead looking at games through the lenses of things like "feminist theory" or "queer theory" or some other abuse of the word theory; trying to legitimize angry people looking for reasons to make everyone else feel bad so they can force situations that make them personally feel good, or even just cash in.

And this is spreading. So many people who have been gaming for a very long time have forgotten the pure euphoric joy of a good gaming session, whether alone or with friends, where you weren't thinking of anything else but how much fun you were having trying to beat this area, or find that secret. Now, industry and gaming veterans are complaining about such trivial nonsense as the name of a trophy or the fact that a female character might *gasp* wear pink. They're taking a game MEANT to showcase the absolute worst forms of humanity that exist, and harping on and on about the fact that a specific group of people are being mistreated, in a game where EVERYONE is mistreated. Of course another group, that aforementioned "40 year old problem" group's, mistreatment doesn't matter at all.

This is an infection, one that can only be considered to be institutionalized amnesia. There's no other explanation for the sheer volume of people who will, with one breath talk about their extensive background in gaming, and with the other completely dismiss any memories of the enjoyment they had as children by insisting that there is this pervasive toxicity within the gaming culture and the gaming industry to purposely create some kind of environment of hatred and disdain for a group of people. The fact that gaming has always been an inclusive medium is lost on them, they have all forgotten that they would game with anyone that had games to play with them.

The friendships created between sexes and races all thanks to gaming are completely lost on these people. Insistent are they that people who don't share their thoughts are blind or simply don't know any better and that gaming needs to change to suit some vaguely defined, militantly expressed and defended ideal arising from a consciousness filled with an unending sense of complete displeasure. Only good can come from that right?

When people insist that gaming should no longer be about fun (seriously, read about that here... http://www.gamasutra.com/bl... and instead be about tackling and examining real world social issues, I don't think I'm the only one that questions what has happened to the child inside of them who only wanted to pick up a controller and have fun persevering through a game as awful as Castlevania 2 or as great Megaman.

If any of you with this mentality actually thinks that gaming will be better thanks to your ideas, ask yourself 2 questions. First. Have you ever even once thought about the people that don't share your ideas and your measuring stick of appropriate gaming? Second. How can you please the unpleasable?

The problem with attitudes like this is that there will always be a problem to argue about. The saying goes "You can't please everyone" so why are you trying to force an impossible situation and ruin the basic fun of playing, and talking about, games?

https://www.youtube.com/wat...

Nicaragua4327d ago

The solution to scenario 2 is to get new friends who arent mindless drones that let the manstream media do their thinking for them.

Luckily for me these topics never come up in real life conversation, either face to face or over steam or psn. In fact if it wasnt for this site i doubt i would be aware of this issue.

DragonKnight4327d ago

Oh you would be, and in ways you wouldn't like. But given your tone, your response would likely be "then I'd stop gaming forever and move on to something else."

Chard4327d ago (Edited 4327d ago )

You're creating problems in your head that aren't there. Nobody actually talks or cares about those things in scenario 2. Gaming is what you make of it; all you need to worry about is whether the games you're looking forward to turn out fun.

Nicaragua4327d ago (Edited 4327d ago )

Yeah, me and my pesky tone.

I'm not entirely convinced that this would impact the games I like, it seems more like a hipster fad that gaming journalism is milking to get their clicks from - and after watching all the Internet Aristocrat videos it seesm to me that that is what is happening. Kotaku (and similar) are boosting the profile of people like Zoe Quinn to get clicks, not to change the face of gaming, and once she no longer gets clicks then she will be yesterdays news.

Today I have played TLOU, Dont Starve, and Mario Kart - how does all this stuff affect me playing these games ? It doesn't, I'm still enjoying my "pure" gaming experience without any of this stuff on my mind or in my games.

In the future I will be playing MGS5, Smash Bros, and BloodBorne - how does this affect me then? I don't think it will.

So I stand by my statement. If your friends talking about this stuff is stopping you enjoying games then tell them to shut up. I don't have that problem, and I'm not seeing any evidence that its gonna affect my "pure" gaming experience once all this dies down (which it will, everything does).

DragonKnight4327d ago

@aerisbueller: First, nice play on Feris Bueller. Great movie. Second, not a generalization, an observable fact that thousands have already seen and have been talking about for nearly a month now.

@Chard: Nope, not creating problems. Showing problems that exist.

"Nobody actually talks or cares about those things in scenario 2."

Then you're not paying attention.

"Gaming is what you make of it; all you need to worry about is whether the games you're looking forward to turn out fun."

Normally I'd agree, until people start wanting to take the fun out of gaming.

http://www.gamasutra.com/bl...

@Nicaragua: Have you heard of Silverstring Media by now? I'm sure you have since you've watched all of IA's videos right? They proudly proclaim that they are a feminist driven company that works closely with developers to change how they develop games. We'll see what your stance is in the future, and is why I said you'd likely say "I'll stop gaming altogether." I meant that the tone of your comment suggested that that would be your final response, not that you were portraying any kind of attitude.

For the record, my friends don't talk about this stuff, but for different reasons. But just because people I know don't talk about it, doesn't mean I don't come across it and see what people are trying to do to gaming.

Nicaragua4327d ago (Edited 4327d ago )

I have heard of Silverstring Media from the Internet Aristocrat videos but I don't see them as any kind of threat just as I don't see The Flat Earth Society as a threat to my scientific beliefs.

The fact that they exist isn't a problem, and them saying they work closely with developers is a non statement until they show which developers and exactly what they have managed to influence - again I'm not seeing it any of the games I play or will be playing in the next 12 months.

And tbh even if these guys get their way (extremely unlikely in the face of macho game giants like COD & GTA) then it doesn't change the experience. If Nintendo bow under pressure and suddenly announce that Mario was a gay transgender woman then it doesn't change my enjoyment of the franchise, its just silly superfluous dialogue that adds nothing to the game.

UnwanteDreamz4326d ago (Edited 4326d ago )

I read that entire thing. If you take away the internet then, all this crap you say is ruining gaming, goes away. I subscribe to a couple of gaming magazines and these issues are rarely brought up. When I games with friends online again these subjects are rarley discussed. I'm not afraid of what these topics will do to my hobbie because my hobbie driven by profit. When the day comes that "gay, feminist, or race sensitive" games become profitable and not niche then they will make them. I will still not buy them and it still wont matter. You dont get to dictate what kind of games get made all by yourself and neither do they. The free market has and always will dictate that. My advice would be to let people have their fight for equality ignore them and get back to what you love gaming. Take a week off from this crap and go play a game. I recently took a break from online gaming media for a couple of days and it was great all fun no negativity.

MrPink20134325d ago (Edited 4325d ago )

Step one, don't take N4G seriously. I notice lots of people here are not here to discuss what they enjoy. Instead many like to argue and annoy each other. That's not meant to generalize because I'm sure there are many decent people here who just like this hobby regardless of platforms.

Step two, take into consideration everyone has a voice now. We read we respond. There is little time given to think before and take time to react. It's why so many get into trouble on Twitter. Think outside the box, the other person may not have the same views as yours, that's OK.

Step three, controversy attracts. We feed ourselves with it. We should be having fun, sharing our experiences. Instead we act immature and want to segregate ourselves as gamers by the platform we play on. Why create rivalries and clicky groups when we all enjoy games?

Step four, the media is partially to blame. They know negativity attracts. Ignore it. Who cares if a game you like got bad reviews. Who cares if the system you don't like sells well or poorly. Who cares if a game looks good on a system you don't own. Why downplay it? Be positive and try not to get involved in the controversy.

Finally games were not better 20 years ago. Let that go, it's a myth. It's like saying Disneyland was better when you were young. Disneyland has improved just like games. If you have a child they will enjoy it just like you used to. Games have gotten smarter, larger and better looking. The way we play then has also advanced. Don't focus just on aaa games either. The real problem is we just want to keep being amazed. Therefore our expectations have increased. That doesn't mean gaming got worse.

+ Show (4) more repliesLast reply 4325d ago
BillytheBarbarian4326d ago

Yep. It's just an internet war. Disconnected players are the majority. They're buying call of duty and madden every year like drones and they don't think twice.

Us internet savvy gamers are a small slice of the pie. If we are loud enough things can change (Xbox one policies), but it all comes down to the vote with your money.

JoelandEllie4327d ago (Edited 4327d ago )

All artforms go though these growing pains. What we have to do is explain our side of the story and add positives to the conversation.

Do more charity based gaming, get politically involved, educate our fellow gamers. Individuals may go away, but attacks will only improve.

Roccetarius4327d ago (Edited 4327d ago )

Having grown up in the 90's, i can without a doubt say that i miss gaming before it became so mainstream. There may not have been so many gullible people playing games, but it was certainly a more pure experience. I wouldn't trade that experience for anything.

With that said, it saddens me to see how easily people accept mediocrity, and i've taken a stand myself by not supporting companies with my wallet.

The Gaming Media is currently so rotten to the core, that i doubt anything short of a major shakeup can change things. Right now we have the SJW issue, and more and more clueless sites supporting something they don't even understand. They're creating a perception for people, both inside and out, that gamers are absolutely terrible.

Oh, and Castlevania: LoS2 was terrible, but that's mainly because of problems with MercurySteam, which caused people to leave.

DragonKnight4327d ago

I actually meant Castlevania 2, not LoS2.

rainslacker4326d ago

I dunno. I think kids that were as young as we were probably see the "purer" side of it all. I have a lot of cousins of various ages, and I can say the young ones have the same excitement that I had, and that dragon talks about, while playing. Young kids tend to be less cynical, and the nostalgia often makes us forget that we did play crappy games as well, but really remember the good ones.

DefenderOfDoom24327d ago (Edited 4327d ago )

Me and my friends have been playing sports games, since ATARI FOOTBALL in the ARCADE in 1978 . We all played MARIO on NES . We also played all the sports games on the SEGA GENESIS . Most of us played RESIDENT EVIL, TOMB RAIDER , CRASH BANDICOOT, MORTAL COMBAT , STREET FIGHTER games on the PSX . We all played 4player split screen QUAKE 2 on PSX , We have been playing EA NHL HOCKEY games on PS3 at least a couple times a week .
Maybe because sports games in AMERICA features players from all different backgrounds and most of my friends ,who i grew up , and still play video games are not white . But the the topic of racism , femininity, sexism, in games , has never come up. We play video games because their fun . I believe 80 to 90 percent of gamers, play video games because their fun. And really do not care about all this other stuff, that has been going on , in the video game industry , these past 2 weeks.
I believe, only 10 to 20 percent of all gamers, go to websites about the video game industry .

annoyedgamer4327d ago

We should also note that ar revenue over the past few years has dried up. What once was a lucrative industry has been replaced by livestreaming. Its no suprise that the characters who are only in it for money are willing to throw an entire industry under the bus for some controversy generated $$$.

If we as gamers allow it then the industry will be lost. This feminist nonsense will not go away its going to get worse in the next 2 years and attmpting to appeal to these trolls only makes them more rabid so we have to resist.

Show all comments (34)
70°

Microsoft Gaming Revenue Drops 7% Year-on-Year, Content and Services Down 5%, Xbox Hardware Down 33%

Microsoft announced its financial results for Q3 of fiscal year 2026, including an update on its gaming Xbox business and more.

Read Full Story >>
simulationdaily.com
Jin_Sakai74d ago (Edited 74d ago )

Not looking good. Hopefully Asha Sharma is able to turn Phil’s disaster around.

dveio74d ago

To me it's still quite remarkable how they can cash-in 5.3bn in revenue in a single quarter, since their hardware is basically dead.

Jingsing74d ago

The stock mark is what makes Microsoft remarkable, They have convinced every institutional and retail investor to just keep piling money into them. Like many big tech giants they are just a big growing pyramid scheme. As long as people keep dropping money into ETF's that cover the market Microsoft will always be liquid. At the same time it is completely stifling innovation and competition. People need to start being more discreet in how they invest their money as it's killing the system.

Tanktopmaster9274d ago

Once they re-evaluate exclusive all will be fine….

S2Killinit74d ago

Riiiiight because people will just flock back to them for one or two games per year.

Jingsing74d ago

15+ years of bad performance is what they call irreparable in business. It is time for them to sell off the assets and get out of entertainment.

Tanktopmaster9274d ago

These declines are on the back of extra revenue received from releasing games like Forza horizon 5 on PlayStation. So I’m being sarcastic here when I said they should go back to exclusives. Killing off a revenue stream from Ps5 sales will only make things worse

Show all comments (13)
40°

Games Done Quick is coming to Europe for the first time with 3 days of Gamescom speedruns

The charity event will be streamed live from Gamescom in August.

Read Full Story >>
videogameschronicle.com
50°

Report: Injustice 3 in Development at NetherRealm Studios

Thanks to the slip-up of an artist working on the title, we now have more evidence that a new Injustice game is in the works.