you can't choose kinect if you are a hardcore gamer. and if you visit n4g you most likely are. so if you defend kinect as the best possible choice then you are a fanboy.
I do agree that kinect will sell much better. not just because of the marketing, but because it will attract a lot of girls and casuals like the wii and the ds. This is why microsoft is smart, they want to make money and not games that people like us will enjoy. However, loosing their hardcore gamers and the millions they make from xbox live subscriptions is in danger.

I think the most important point is missing in this article. How much space do you have? I have plenty of space to use Move. I could have enough room for Kinect if I empty out my livingroom and move my TV to another wall. No thanks on that. Knect just isn't a good idea unless you live in a big house with a huge room and lots of empty space. I live in an upstairs apartment too and I don't want to get evicted from jumping up all the time.

He really rambles on without giving much info so read this opinion instead. Neither peripheral has proven itself worth a holiday purchase, yet they will both sell out. I'm telling you, I bought the Move a month ago, and guess what: It works great. Guess what else: There's nothing i want to play with it. I'm hearing the same thing about Kinect. Maybe these technological advances will result in a great gaming experience someday, but not by Christmas and probably not even this gen. Its fun, but if its not the best way to play a game, it gets old fast. Save your money, or buy 2 or 3 hardcore titles this holiday instead of plunking it down on a hollow experience.

@gigaware , dude when have i been saying the 360 is for casuals ? i have said kinect is for casuals yes but i havent said the 360 itself is as you can enjoy decent core games on 360 aswell . p.s LMFAO at fact you have the nerve to even say anything about anybody when you are 1st in every kinect article trying to convince them its the best thing since sliced bread

i got 2 moves and nav on launch and a good amounr of move compatible games and the only thing i find myself coming back for more of is tabble tennis so far- the controller works great but need more move only games!

from my experience the patched up ones dont work that well, resi 5 has a terrible control scheme (not really the controllers fault), mag is suprisingly playable tho but not a patch on mouse keyboard setup

i want bushido blade move! a time crisis thats not plan HORRIBLE would have rather had a 1-4 compelation pack (since when was time crisis about spraying?)

i really wanted move to be the control scheme to get me into fps's but with more auto-aim that even a dual analogue whats the point (yeah thats right controller fps's players your not in the same league as mouse and keyboard it aims for you)

that said im still optimistic for a good lightgun-fps in the future cuz thats what it'll take to get me into fps's

however that said i dont find kinnect even a little bit apealing other than in a party environment (voice control doesnt count that could be done with a head set and work better for it) altho i ill probs get one cuz im a nerd and a sucker to new tech

how about like parappa the rapper kinnect that could be cool, maybe?

"kick punch its all in the mind if you wanna test me im sure youll find..."

what would really be the winner- kinnect camera (with upgraded framerate) replacing the pseye used in conjuction with move controllers on the pc- WIN

Sorry people of the gaming world and gaming media. I can use my Move all I like and no one can stop me.I could care less what Oprah, Ellen,Beber and the rest say. All Kinect is so far is a device that plays mini games and dance games. Everyone tries to hide the fact that Joyride controls like crap, Fighter Uncaged is even worse then the Fight,Adrenalin Junkies is boring, Sonic riders is pointless. It happened just as i thought it would.That people would ignore all the negative scores the games get and cling to what ever positive ones there are.If you take off the fanboys glasses, Kinect has no more or less good or bad titles then Move has.They both have not so hot beginner titles just like any system or motion control devices did. The scores are practically the same.

So can people do me a favor and stop the lies and exaggerations please especially the ones where suddenly Move doesn't work properly despite the positive reviews and claims from others. Kinect and Move will get better but they are both in the same boat as far as I am concerned

Kinect=innovation&revoluti on

Move=old tecnology,clone of the wiimote.

Kinect wins,no if or but!

I think we need to consider how we define success. Many people speculated that the Wii would be a toy. Years later, it has left the 360 and PS3 in the dust. What is makes a console more successful - a console that is more powerful or one that sells more units?

With the new products, Move looks pretty cool. I have always hated how inaccurate the Wiimote is. I love the idea of having a super accurate controller with the power of the PS3. That said, I believe that Kinect will double or triple move's sales. Before you kill me for being a fanboy, hear me out.

MS is marketing Kinect to a new audience. Watch the commercials. You see sons and dads racing against one another. You see soccer moms and daughters playing together. These are players the console didn't have yet. The Wii succeeded because it wasn't intimidating and mom's understood it. Don't underestimate the fact that Oprah and Ellen both heralded this product. I picked up a Kinect on launch day and the person behind me was a soccer mom.

I am an avid gamer that loves my fps's. My 8 year old son has played many a Reach game with me, but to this point, my five year old daughter has never wanted to play my 360. That is why I bought Kinect. I love watching my daughter dance around as you plays Kinect adventures. It is hysterical to watch her jump in the air as she plays that river game. It is just fun and my whole family is in on it.

On the other side you have Move. An awesome product that plays to the same audience the console already had. It is hard to imagine that someone that didn't already want a PS3 is now going to want it because of Move.

This isn't about whether move is better or kinect is better. I don't really care about that. In the end, Move might have better games, but there is no doubt that Kinect will sell more.

isnt it gorgeous how we treat animals.

That’s Zuckermans famous pig.

Move controller was extremely accurate great times back then

That definitely would have been the absolute worst time for stick drift to happen...

I always wanted a true to life surgery simulator for PSVR1. I always knew those Move controllers were precise AF under the proper conditions.

Move was a very accurate device under good conditions. Dr Marks even wanted to open it up for hobbyists and developers to extract more data to do more things. I even seen him use it for space, astronaut like simulations.

Sony always had the tech. They just needed the software to go with it. PS Move limit was not having an analog stick. Which it seems the PS5 controller made up for that.

I would like to see them use PS VR 2 for surgery or something with that eye tracking built in.

At least it wasn’t used for a mini-sub