All Channels
Popular
730°

Developers compare Nintendo 3DS graphics with PS3 and Xbox360

With more and more developers getting their hands on the Nintendo 3DS additional comments about the system arise. Recent hardware speculations where supported by various developers comparing the graphics of the Nintendo 3DS to PC, Playstation 3 and Xbox360, saying the portable device can match the power, but only do to the screen resolution.

Miroque5716d ago

True story. The DS is a bomb in sense of portable graphics.

Jamegohanssj55716d ago

They're trolling obviously.

TGSI

ProjectVulcan5715d ago (Edited 5715d ago )

Top screen is 800 x 240 (400 x 240 each eye) So rendering 400 x 240 with offset for 3D, It doesnt take twice as much performance to render 3D though and fill that screen. Even so, 800 x 240 is a mere 192k pixels, plus the lower touch screen which is usually devoid of intensive 3D visuals completely, very small graphics load.

1280 x 720 = 921600 pixels. 3DS is at best doing about 1/5th the pixels as the home consoles, in truth its less because as i said 3D doesnt actually halve performance, maybe takes 20-40 percent depending on the methods.

I would say that the visuals fall short of the current home consoles even with a fraction of their resolution, but some games beat out the previous generation i.e Xbox/PS2/Cube. Thats not bad. Its probably slower in raw numbers performance than the original xbox, but with improved GPU architecture acceleration/feature support and software tools make it capable of visuals beyond it in some areas. Just a question of efficiency improvements since the Geforce 4 era (Xbox GPU was a similar to an underclocked Ti4200)

It was only until the Geforce 6 era where architectures really focused on pixel shading performance and fillrate with raw polygon transformation less important. Certainly 3DS pixel shading ability looks beyond the aged Geforce 4 in xbox in many of the games shown.

avengers19785715d ago

It will probably have the best visuals for any handheld. But will be a frycry from home consoles, except there console I'm sure it will be able to do comparable graphics with the Wii.

PopEmUp5715d ago

if the PSP2 it will be the second best

hakis865715d ago

That are way behind the Iphone, I don't see how the 3DS could even come close to the PS3 or the Xbox 360.
They'll have to convince me with some HD video at least.

N4g_null5715d ago

It's not about those specs it's the shader output and hardwired effects. Try doing smoke real smoke on the iPhone lol the draw call will be equal to the bit rate of your smoke. This effect is almost free on the 3ds.

That isn't even true on the hd consoles. Suffice to say certain effects are actualy in the silicon so it's already been optimized and the gpu in this thing is way better than the consoles because of it.

Most did not think nintendo could even do this and yet they have. It really is that good shader wise.

Sure Sony can do better but they would have to show more devs some solid hardware because devs are loving this new ds.

What would be funny is it can out do the wii right now with out tweaks. I'm not sure why you guys are so affraid? It's a handheld yet I have to admit nintendo always makes there home system way more powerful than their handheld.

Now an minihdmi port would be murder.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 5715d ago
outrageous5716d ago (Edited 5716d ago )

There is no way the graphics will look like the multi-core and multi-threading PS3/360. I have no problem with hyping a new handheld but that's just pooh really.

ABizzel15716d ago (Edited 5716d ago )

I agree.

The 3DS doesn't have the specs to compete with the consoles. Street Fighter 4 on the 3DS looks good, but it doesn't have nearly as much detail as the console versions, and that's on a much smaller screen, imagine what it'd look like if it was unscaled on a 30" TV or larger.

The 3DS looks great, but not Xbox 360 or PS3 great, it's PS3 Collection titles at best from what I've seen so far, which is completely acceptable for a handheld. Comparisons of 3DS games look nearly identical to that of current PSP games, which is last gen graphically and no PS2, Gamecube, or Xbox title can compare with PS3 or 360 titles graphically (graphically no, artistically yes).

Later on we may see some titles that can compete with early PS3 and 360 titles on the 3DS, but as of now I've yet to see PS3 or 360 quality on the 3DS.

The 3DS is a 3D Wii, and for a handheld that's fine.

Cevapi885716d ago

article makes no sense...its one thing to take what Nintendo says about the device and then put up pics of the games, when there are no pics/shots that have been revealed to the public of pure gameplay besides the e3 press videos

hay5715d ago (Edited 5715d ago )

Actually when you spin it a little, you could compare them. 3DS won't be HD, res is 854x480 so this won't hit hardware hard. Also with this screen resolution, there's no need for higher res textures PS3/Xbox use, with small speakers there's no need for 7.1 audio, so with small screen visual effect may be somewhat close to being comparable to multiplats.

N4g_null5715d ago

Understand take a breath it's a hd like handheld console. It does what the hd consoles do well shaders. It is also specialized hardware with only a few standards to worry about. The gpu is very to the point.

It is what the psp could have been. Totally crushes the tegra in power output ratios and it's cus even the CPU helps out if you want ah al ps3 style or xbox style.

You can choose to support 3d or not which would maximize your bandwidth.

No one is going to spill all the beans though your gonna have to wait.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 5715d ago
Elimin85716d ago

Why are Wii's still in production.. Would be a shame to see their handheld compared to a power house console as oppose to their own "next gen" system....

My 2Cents...

Yi-Long5716d ago

... I hope it will come with a HDMI-port, so I can attach it to my plasma when I'm at home...

SolidSystem5716d ago

cause your plasma TV does touch? you are going to look down at the screen for that reason alone. seems pointless to have it go to a plasma.

Yi-Long5716d ago

... not it doesn't do touch...

... but if the 3DS is so powerful, they should attach an option to also use it as a home-console which you can then hook up to your TV, and wirelessly connect to with your wireless controller... so you can play games which don't need the touch-screen or the whole 3D effect...

N4g_null5715d ago

Who knows what the end product will have. The mini hdmi would be sweet.

You know what it would cool if it was good at upscaling also. They do make USB component inputs things could get interesting lol

It would be cool if you could vc games of the wii on here lol right before the next system comes out.

I think you might one to tried coding or making some shaders on pc or the iPhone before you judge the impact of the 3ds graphics power.

Just think the shaders of the pc with lower resolution, lower textures and slightly lower geometry. Then realize this is all for a small screen.

Oh yeah it does smoke really really well.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 5715d ago
gtamike5716d ago

The first DS graphics are lower than PS1 graphics.

E.G. No game on DS looks better than Resident Evil 3 (PS1)

EYEamNUMBER15716d ago

i pray to allah, buddah, jesus any of them i seriously pray that you are joking you seriously can't be that slow

considering that the DS has more power than a N64.... YOUR SERIOUS?

Matthew945716d ago

Resident Evil 1 Graphics = Resident Evil 3 Graphics

DS did Resident evil 1 flawlessly

PirosThe4th5716d ago

do you people realize DS screen resolution is 2/3 of the actual psone resolution...

it looks better because it's smaller... thats all... and nah... the n64 is way more powerful... you can't compare the 2...

Galaxia5716d ago (Edited 5716d ago )

Matt94. When did you last play RE3? I assure you RE3 looks a heck ton better than RE1. RE3 is probably the best looking game of the entire PS1/N64 era. It even stands up well to some early PS2 games. Add that the artwork is gorgeous and you have a great looking game.

Nothing on the DS has been near that good looking.

Also RE1 on the DS didn't look as good as RE1 on the PS1 in 1996.

Mini Mario5716d ago

Wasnt the launch game for the DS, >> Mario 64??

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 5716d ago
Leio5715d ago

Gimmi the name of those Devs i´ll avoid their game from now on they seems lost touch with reality.

vhero5715d ago

I reckon we will be talking more like iphone/PSP/android graphics.

chazjamie5715d ago (Edited 5715d ago )

they should wasted their time and compared it to the wii. since they wasting their comparing it to .. i dont know.... a freakin xbox and ps3

Gago5715d ago

1. @Miroque LOL look at all your disagrees, they couldn't even take joke

2. devs know more than fanboys, they NEVER said it has better graphics/power than ps3/xbox, they just said in a sense the 3DS is comparable

sony fanboys are soo retarded

N4g_null5715d ago

No their scared that if nintendo can make a handheld like this that the console Is going to be really powerful then and it'll be put soon. Maybe even soon enough to render the low sales of the move incapable of extending the ps3 life.

This system may actualy be the catalyst for the next gen.

Sure it doesn't do hd graphic res wise but shader wise it does he'll most hd games arn't even hd anyway.

The 3ds is hd like tech in your hands. That means alot. iPhone just isn't getting it done. Pspgo well ...... Ummm even pachyer hates it and he's a big Sony cheerleader.

TVippy5709d ago

It 'shows'. Especially in MGS, which looks exactly like MGS3 graphics wise.

+ Show (7) more repliesLast reply 5709d ago
portablegaming5716d ago

It could never win on the big screen but portable it rocks.

Sorano5716d ago

That is CRAP! Everybody knows PS3 has the best graphics. Just look at Uncharted 2!!!

franktheprankreturns5716d ago

I must say, did you ever play Halo Reach?

Lovable5716d ago

@franktheprankreturns

Dude, you shouldn't have spoken. You just made yourself look retarded with that post.

Nitrowolf25716d ago

Halo Reach isn't in the same league as graphics as UC2, KZ2, even Crysis 2

It is def an improvement over Halo games but not something to be bragging about

mrcash5716d ago

Halo reach is actually 720p, and when it comes to visual quality and scale UC2,Killzone2,and gow3 don't come close.

ChickeyCantor5716d ago

" but not something to be bragging about"

Funny cause someone is just screaming how PS3 has the best gfx while its not even HIS product.

No one should be so ignorant and brag about any of these gfx.
Games look good, they can only look better.

bobcostus5716d ago

ps3 guys are going to eat you alive frank... bad idea

DasBunker5716d ago

"when it comes to visual quality and scale UC2,Killzone2,and gow3 don't come close. "

Bwahahaha.. i always come to N4G for my sh!ts and giggles of the day.

Misterhbk5716d ago

did you just compare the scale of Halo Reach to God of War 3

forget the visual quality and all that other stuff. The scale of God of War 3 has never even come close to being matched before in a game. Well, SotC has the same level scale but was ps2 and not HD so can't compare it. At least not until its re-released next year. Anyways. Slap yourself for that comment please.

fuckitimout5716d ago (Edited 5716d ago )

halo reach has the best graphics to date. It beats uc2, kz2, mgs4, gow3 and even the pc's precious crysis. I say this with full confidence and until proven otherwise a ps3 can't hold a stick to the raw power of the 360. Dream on ps3 users -HALO IS BACK FULL FORCE!!!!!!!!

expect for halo to steal sales from kz3 also and I wont say I told you so

mrcash5716d ago

I sure did, Everyone talks about GOW3s scale but come one guys, we had no control of the camera to truly enjoy everything that is suppose to be happening. They only let you see a few things like the battle with chronos whats he like 1000 feet and I know its probably to fit him on screen but all you really do is fight on his arm which isnt to impressive. The scale of GOW3 was limited by the lack of camera control.

What good would it do if bungie or guerilla games said we have 3000 individual AI running at the same time but you can only see 50 of them.

AKA5716d ago (Edited 5716d ago )

I understand that HALO has a lot of fans because is a" fun" game to play but i did not kneew they are so 5tup..s

Eamon5716d ago

wow this comment thread is really off-topic

Gilliand5716d ago

Wow this whole thread is full of retards or trolls.

Galaxia5716d ago

Stop whining about camera movement. Not every game needs a fully 3 dimensional camera, because some games just wouldn't work as good with them.

If GOW3 had a 3D camera, it would be so annoying trying to position it in a fight, and you would likely miss half of the epic moments because you were looking at the ground or something stupid like that.

I like director controlled camera's like in God of War, that way I never miss anything cool.

MiloGarret5715d ago

Very nice trolling skills, impressive indeed.

5715d ago
hassi945715d ago (Edited 5715d ago )

I own an xbox and a gaming pc (primarily xbox), and no way is halo reach better looking than uncharted. It's a great looking game, but textures aren't great and it isn't AMAZING looking. Not as good as U2 though, and I've hardly even played U2...

Nemo885715d ago (Edited 5715d ago )

Halo reach is NOT 720p.. as confirmed by digital foundry.. and they love the game. But its not 720p but close:
http://www.eurogamer.net/ar...

(read 3rd paragraph in)

If you then go factor in that they use dodgy temporal aliasing (resulting in 'ghosting' effect).. and its a KO for Reach. The Mighty Uncharted 2..game of the year... back in 2009!

+ Show (15) more repliesLast reply 5715d ago
Zyrando5716d ago

Maybe PS3 has better Hardware, but most Games look better on XBOX360, because the programming for the xbox cpu is not that difficult and complex

Nitrowolf25716d ago (Edited 5716d ago )

um Uncharted 1, Uncharted 2, LBP,LBP2, Killzone 2, Killzone 3, MGS4, FF13 versus, Heavy Rain, God of war 3, The last Gaurdian, GT5, MLB the show,Portal 2 they all say hello

but i see what you mean by most games as in Multiplat
Hey there are a good number of them look identicle and some even better

plus I i am getting tired of hearing "It to complex to develop for"
how long ago was that even said? it has been 4 years and multiplat dev are just getting use to it now

Devs need to start doing it this way

PS3-------Port to-------360

I mean i am sick of seeing Multiplat games being held back, FF13 looks so much better on PS3 then 360, many other games that do PS3 first as development then port they usually end up being the same in graphics

gamingisnotacrime5716d ago

lol, either a troll or a victim of complete ignorance

nycredude5716d ago

So what all those games you claim looks minutely better on the 360 is undoubtedly superior in graphics on the PC, but you guys love to conveniently forget that when arguing graphics.

OT this is rubbish. What resolution is the DS3 rendering at? If they want to compare the graphics of that to the big boy consoles then output it to an hdtv and let's see. Don't blow smoke up my ass with this BS.

ChickeyCantor5716d ago

"Devs need to start doing it this way

PS3-------Port to-------360 "

It doesn't work that way.
Both versions are usually build simultaneously, its more time and cost efficient.

Nitrowolf25716d ago (Edited 5716d ago )

Sidar it is more cheap if they port the game over rather then work on both titles at the same time
in most cases it is like that
Many of EA games are Port
2K does ports also
Se does ports for many of their games
Capcom ports

Not many devs actually work on both title both ground up, they usually just port the game over and do a few tweaks

mrcash5716d ago

For the 360 to match the ps3s graphics it would need and additional core, the games basically operate on 2 cores with the third used for the os. ps3 has those 6 spus and at 2 threads per core a quad would do it for the 360

JLeVRT5716d ago

@Nitrowolf2
You DO realise that those games you listed are ALL PS3 exclusives? So they are gonna look WAY better on PS3 because devs can use alot more Disk space.

Nitrowolf25716d ago (Edited 5716d ago )

"but i see what you mean by most games as in Multiplat "
did you read that part?

there are a good number of PS3 multiplat that look better or identicle
my point i was saying to Zyrando was about that BS complex stuff that people been saying about the PS3 for years after a few devs have said it.

At least 4 of those games i have said are developed by third party devs which should give no excuse for that hardware complex if they have devs creating these great games.
Portal 2 valve- EA (which is not exclusive but devs said PS3 version for console will be the better vrsion)
Heavy Rain- Quntic dream
MGS4- Konami
FF13- Square Enix

also
"So they are gonna look WAY better on PS3 because devs can use alot more Disk space."

So what exactly is preventing them from using more space on a multiplat game?
Simple answer

+ Show (6) more repliesLast reply 5716d ago
xandmar5716d ago

WOW. Took a while for someone to say that.

Mini Mario5716d ago (Edited 5716d ago )

Yeh but the ps3 is old news now. But dont worry u still have 6 more years to go as sony was going for a 10 year plan.

"um Uncharted 1, Uncharted 2, LBP,LBP2, Killzone 2, Killzone 3, MGS4, FF13 versus, Heavy Rain, God of war 3, The last Gaurdian, GT5, MLB the show,Portal 2 they all say hello "

Hello. How are you.

matey5716d ago (Edited 5716d ago )

yes but the 3DS has dual core cpu and has dedicated shaders powerful ones at that and can do ps3 graphics its that simple the character models being used in revelations Capcoms words are the exact models from ps3 polygon for polygon end of so the wii can do abit better polygon count than 3DS with better lighting but need abit of work to get the same shaders but all in all wii at best is a 360 in 480p and 3DS at best is alomst a wii so in order for me is 1#PS3/2#360/wii#3DS i say this because the wii has so many games that graphically hold up to any 360 game yes any but because the nintendo advertise the familt image alot devs dont pour the same love into development but the wii has decent specs and in pure numbers the 360 is way more powerful but in pure results the wii games like silent hill/smash bros/Monster hunter 3/Mario galaxy 2/darkside chronicles ect all have 360 level polygon counts and all support HDR/AA/MOTION BLUR i mean that new sonic game looks like a 360 game Epic micky looks better than any game on the 360 that uses them style graphics banjoo kazzokie ect the wii does all the next gen graphics stencil shadows,normal mapping,everything way too much to list the Conduit2/Black ops/the grinder will all have 360 graphics so wii has 360 graphics at 480p they dont always get used and in multi platform games the wii doesnt get used to its full potential fact so im going off the devs that actually try on the wii not the ps3/360 lick ass fan boy devs.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 5715d ago
Nibbler5716d ago

The 3DS is capable of amazing graphics. Just look at the Resident Evil Game!

BYE5716d ago

Still, even compaing it with PS3 / 360 is a joke.

Mini Mario5716d ago

Not really hardware improves very quickly. Plus no one knows, so why say either ??

matey5715d ago

right why is it u know what the 360 with its dual core doesnt mean shit m8 the 3DS is a tiny device with dedicated shaders and all sorts of bells and whistles get a life the 3DS also has dual core cpu tech aswel as 360 the mhz/ghz mean nothing as what graphics u get out of a system its the features put in the gpu and thats that its all to do with fill rate really 3DS has 1.6 billion wii has 1.9 billion end of 360 does 2 billion to 4 billion pixels per sec so the 360 has twice but has more than twice the pixels to fill with using 720p/1080p it goes on the resolution of your games and the fillrate and the ratio is the wii is exact same performance as 360 at 480p end of or games like Mario galaxy 2 and shamsh bros wouldnt exist neither would MH3 and Darkside/Silent hill shattered memorys.

CobraKai5716d ago

But unless I missed something, there isn't any gameplay footage yet? SFIV is close, but I don't think it looks as good as the PS360. What is undeniable is that 3DS looks a whole generation ahead of Wii

CrazyForGames5716d ago

capcom and inafune have already said the RE 3DS trailer is all in game

TheGameFoxJTV5716d ago

Because developers ALWAYS tell the truth to their fans.

corneliuscrust5716d ago (Edited 5716d ago )

played the RE demo?

Are they ALL lying as well? Because they could control the camera.

Why can't people around here accept that it was in game? Oh... because it's not a sony product. Gotcha.

good job n4g

EYEamNUMBER15716d ago

ehm you mean like when kojima said the MGS4 cut scenes were all in game?
or like when takeuchi said the the re4 and re5 cut scenes were all in game?

yeah those devs are all such liars (sarcasm)

fact of the matter is capcom and inafune have stated that what was shown is running on the in game engine and there is no reason to believe other wise because if you disbelieve that then i don't see how you can believe anything any developer ever says

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 5716d ago
Gitaroo5716d ago

it can never achieve graphics like epic citadel on the iphone 4 period. 512 MB ram on the iphone 4 >>>>> 64+4 vram on 3ds.

ChickeyCantor5716d ago

So with my 6Gb of ram in my pc, the 360 and Ps3 are totall crap?
Iphone is NOT designed towards games, its designed as a multi-purpose device.
So it will need additional ram to run all kinds of things.

O and yeah Ram == epic LOL

TheGameFoxJTV5716d ago (Edited 5716d ago )

I want your phone to have REAL games and not fart apps. Then we can talk, otherwise just STFU and go make a phone call.

corneliuscrust5716d ago (Edited 5716d ago )

he finally got multitasking

walker015716d ago

its not even good at doing that :P

DatNJDom815716d ago

Shits all over your precious iphone. hehehehehe!

matey5715d ago

512mb on iphone 4 and guess what 4GBRAM on 3DS u plum VRAM is different

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 5715d ago
Show all comments (149)
90°

New Pokemon Ultra Sun/Ultra Moon Key Art From a Retail Poster

This image basically confirms that in Ultra Sun/Ultra Moon we will be seeing an alternate story. While it has been stated by Nintendo multiple times that this was the case, they were never really clear on it.

Read Full Story >>
beyond-gaming.net
Antnee5343163d ago

Why in fucks name did the designs for the mc make it through the planing stages of development? They are by far the worse thing pokemon have produced.

MeteorPanda3162d ago

but...you customize your own characters now? l dont like that boys neck. holy shit it's about as strong as a twig

Antnee5343162d ago

I understand that, but if you pick a boy you get the worse choices.

MeteorPanda3161d ago

oh for sure. The franchise just shits on the male version more and more per new entry, lol

Antnee5343161d ago

It's so weird being that the player base is 70/30 male you know. You would think that they would give the males a better choice selection.

70°
7.5

Hey! Pikmin Review - Culture of Gaming

Hey! Pikmin is brand new adventure set on the Nintendo 3DS as Captain Olimar's ship crash lands on a mysterious alien planet.

Read Full Story >>
cultureofgaming.com
TargusX3162d ago

Every time I see 'released on Steam' my heart sinks. Why don't these guys release on GOG instead?

80°
8.0

Metroid: Samus Returns Review - Culture of Gaming

Beware Space Pirates. Beware Metroids. Samus Aran is back and she is locked & loaded.

Read Full Story >>
cultureofgaming.com