They should just rename Kinnect the Skittles device.

i already have animals. 4 dogs 1 turtle and some rats on my kitchen
why the hell would i want kinectimals

"The whole Minority Report hand waving gimmick is likely to get old very quickly and only seems convenient if you don't want to pick up a controller between games" - $150 seems a bit steep just for this convenience!

"despite the much higher tech behind Kinect the end result is still almost exactly the same as playing the Wii - in terms of the responsiveness of your actions and the nature of the games themselves." - So why not just get a Wii, its cheaper?

"the lack of any buttons or physical controller is as much a hindrance to some games as it is a help to others." - Why get a devicde that limits the scope of games you can play?

"The PlayStation Move may look more like the Wii remote, but the experience of playing Kinect is much more similar to Nintendo's home console." - and why would I want the experience of playing the wii on the 360?