LAME

wont even give the site a click....
no game is perfect but to write about it the day the game is released especially after the game is getting high 9s by many sites...just shows how much they have NOTHING of interest to write about
dont give sites like this clicks...

Shall I tell you why most of you should dislike the game? Because when you buy it it'll be so much better. Let's all go back to April shall we remember the you bought GTA and called it the greatest game ever? A few days later you called it the biggest disappointed? That's because you where hyped for it, I HATED MW2 but I was never disappointed by it. If you hate something it's hard to be disappointed by it unless it turns out to be great, a win win situation.

The site is down (I wonder why) but I would not give it any hits anyway. Jason 360 if you cannot discuss the topic at hand then stfu because really no one wants to read a 11yr olds rants about your imaginary 360 which you probably don't even own.

This news is to make reading and has absolutely no interest...

I think Google need to do some work on the translator!!! They only sound like minor gripes though. Looking forward to getting my hands on it.

Articles like this are cancer for journalism. What's the point? Post your thoughts, but don't try to influence others to hate a game.

Why so obsessed with finding fucking faults with games?

There is a saying: "You should appreciate everything you see and know for what it is, and not look for faults" or something like that.

The point is, why is no just appreciate games for what they are and stop making these ridiculous articles about basically "why you shouldn't play this game".

Fuck this pisses me off and excuse my language. Eat this instead: "Name 5 good reason why you should be able to play these games". Considering all the whining and complaining it should be hard to find one.

Frys Electronics has the game in store and online for $49.99. Thought id give people the heads up on this deal.

Already played 10 hours of it. So far:

- Some of the best graphics on ANY platform.
- Great voice acting. (John Marston sounds like Jason Lee though. I'm not sure where they're getting Bill Paxton.)
- Brilliant new gameplay mechanics. (Hold X to stay at the same pace as other people on horses, as an example.)
- If it breathes, you can kill it. I love that! I was hunting for a good two hours last night. It's so fun!
- It's more like Bully than GTA. By that, I mean it has an interesting storyline and the missions aren't repetitive.
- It's freaking massive.
- You WILL be addicted.

Backlash from a bunch of jaded elitists who are never satisfied and carry around a sense of entitlement. Instead of being happy with a content packed, top shelf game that gives more than enough bang for your buck, they only focus on what negatives they can find. I don't know what is worse, the groups who do this or the pixel counters who over analyze every blade of grass and detail in between, nearly giving themselves a heart attack over which version might be slightly sharper resolution-wise, even though most will never even tell the difference.

I dont think that anyone should hate the game, but i must admit after putting in 10 hours into the game (PS3) the game is very over rated, not in the sense that people love it, but in reviews, the reviews scores are way too high for this game.RDR should have got a score no higher than 8.5 the lowest, or 9 the highest.

My eyes are bad then. It didn't look sub HD to me and if anybody knows their history the wild west wasn't about bustling cities it was about small towns and shootouts. Rockstar is really really good with their games despite being sub HD or not they still look good. Now Fallout 3 is a great game with mediocre visuals; however, if it all it takes to make a game with great story, acting, atmosphere, immersion, lots of videogame content and open world game to boot minus the visuals is okay in my book i.e. fallout 3, assasins creed franchise, etc.................

game is solid