All Channels
Popular
150°

Battle over Batman: Arkham Asylum AA

During recent days, you could see a fierce battle between AMD and Nvidia PR teams over Batman: Arkham Asylum and the fact that PhysX and AA works only when you run it on Nvidia GPUs, while on AMD cards the game worked, but without the in-game AA.

Nvidia's team worked with developers and designed the AA engine by themselves. That's a clear fact, and thus the game does indeed look better when paired up with an Nvidia GPU. On the other hand, AMD's PR team is adamant that Nvidia had a lot to do with the fact that the game simply doesn't like AMD GPUs. According to a statement made by AMD's Ian McNaughton, AMD did provide the developer with a solution, but it didn't make its way into the final release of the game.

Read Full Story >>
fudzilla.com
aGameDeveloper6088d ago

They may have declined AMD's help if the work that NVIDIA did was proprietary and not easy to split out.

yippie1234y6088d ago

seems like amd always gets the short end of the stick.. imo

Kakkoii6088d ago

Here's the whole situation:

Nvidia worked hard to implement AA in the game. AMD could have gotten involved at least a bit to have it enabled for them also. It's not Nvidia's freaking job to get something working for AMD. Nvidia did not stop something from working for AMD, they merely added a feature to a game that was enabled for Nvidia, since Nvidia is the one who added it in. Just like how Nvidia added PhysX to the game.

Major_Tom6088d ago

Lol. Kak, I would normally agree with you but this is Nvidia's fault, they're so brash and anti-competitive.

You sign up for TWIMTBP program. Nvidia also says Physx is open source, my ass it is.

Kakkoii6088d ago

But what exactly don't you agree about in this situation though? Nvidia implemented something in a game that otherwise wouldn't have been. There is no reason at all for them to say, "oh hey, I guess well do AMD's job for them also and enable it on their GPU's."

That would be giving AMD a free ride.

Major_Tom6088d ago

You're giving precedence to Nvidia even though they're seeing AMD as having faceless customers. It doesn't matter they've been playing dirty for awhile now.

likedamaster6088d ago

Nvidia doesn't have to help the competition in any way. I see nVidia's point of view now. AMD sound like a bunch of crybabies in my opinion.

Major_Tom6088d ago

Riiiight.

This isn't helping the competition this is draconian tactics and not what PC gaming has been up to now. Nvidia is really giving the middle fingers to PC gamers as of lately and a few people are still taking it.

Kakkoii6088d ago (Edited 6088d ago )

Major_tom.. I don't think you understand the situation here. Nothing about this is freaking Draconian. Nvidia worked to get AA implemented in that damn game! There is no f*cking reason why they would be obligated to set it to automatically work on AMD's GPU's.

Nvidia did something to improve a game for use on their GPU's. AMD can get involved if they want to, they chose not to, big whoop. Don't bash Nvidia for wanting to improve something.

And when it comes to PhysX, Nvidia has been very open with wanting to have it run on AMD GPU's. AMD has merely refused because it's an API owned by Nvidia. Yes Nvidia could port it to OpenCL. But CUDA is a more efficient GPU computing platform. It's not code that just runs on basic shaders, there's a whole GPU architecture to it that allows it to run very fast. Plus it uses C++ code, with some minor changes of course. Which makes it very easy for developers to port their windows applications to CUDA. Where as with OpenCL you would have to learn a whole new coding language and rewrite your code from the ground up.

darkmurder6087d ago

Sigh AMD is like Opera whinging that MS doesn't put their software on its platform, you know its there's, they have no obligation to put it on at all why should the opponent's get a free ride?

Show all comments (12)
90°

Ranking the Batman Arkham Games: Every Arkham Title Ranked

Discover the best Batman Arkham games ranked from Asylum to Knight, including Origins, VR and more, with a focus on combat, story, and world design.

Read Full Story >>
spawningpoint.com
80°

Years Later, Batman Arkham: Asylum's Intro Scene Still Sends Chills Down Your Spine

Batman: Arkham Asylum's powerful intro paves the way to an excellent gameplay experience, even almost 15 years later.

60°

The best Batman games you can play right now

Want to be The Batman? Of course you do! Check out GameSpew's list of the best games that let you become the Caped Crusader.

Read Full Story >>
gamespew.com
Muigi569d ago

Wish they would give Arkham Knight a current gen update.

Exvalos560d ago

Game already looks better then most current gen games