all of of them stepped up their game compared to what thy showed last year so they all won

personally though id say none of em did it was golden sun lol x]

i think Sony won but only because Kojima and his obvious lack of love for MGS:Rising. It really takes off some of the power of that announcement when the man behind the series is showing an obvious disdain for that title.

Other than that, Ms could of showed some new ip's, that's all the conference lacked.

B+ for MS
A for Sony

I wasn't impressed by Sony's conference. Rock*'s PS3 exclusive had no release date or footage. Waste of time announcing it. I have no idea why they demonstrated AC2 with no great benefits over the 360 version. The Last Guardian was leaked, so it took away the surprise and again no release date. GT5 = no release date. They focused on games that are going to come out next year or so and didn't focus on their holiday line-up. Uncharted 2 looks great, but don't they have other games coming out this year?

Microsoft came with nothing and left with an impressive fall line-up.

Sony.

sony owns in all terms this e3.

gamers won. nobody can say there isn't something they're excited about.

Microsoft.

And i must say easily... You can argue but Sony came with their A game this E3... Not to mention Sonys conferences always seem to be more interesting to me?!? Not sure why.

360 I thought was terrible, it was more of the same old. I dont see how you go from having all these games to literally not putting out anything all year thus far...

id say sony kept my attention all the way thru. nintendo was better than last year,of course,but wasnt anything exciting.

Nintendo was horrible and MS jsut a bunch of multiplats, games we already knew and copy of eyetoy. the few exclusives looked horrible

It's being developed by Rock* North,the same guys behind GTA.

Don't worry it'll rock :)

SONY WAS GOOD BUT I DIDNT SEE WHITE KNIGHT

Sega.

just had a much better show wen it comes to games

MS for me with Sony very close

Droids will say Sony

Bots will say Microsoft

which one do you follow under shadow??? bot?

Flamebait

They were both good. Nintendo and Ubisoft were pants.
End of.

Sony won with the footages of uncharted 2 and God of war 3.

SONY= A
Microsoft= A-
Nintendo= B-

I didn't think SONY could Beat MS after their conference...but they certainly did....I almost gave them an A+. Nintendo surprised me at the end of theirs....a little better than average though.

Sony clearly stole E3 from MS and equaled or stole the things from the best announcements from the MS conference.
Nintendo did enough to survive, but seem to be a very confused company of who their audience and what their image is these days, much better than last year.

I wanted to see more Ratchet, but they showed it in a compiled trailer.

everyone who think otherwise should be beaten with steel pipes. Seriously a new halo? IS THAT THE BEST YOU CAN COME UP WITH? Chicken chaser and f@g ass bladestar can go f themselves. God damn retards. OH WOW I'M SO ORIGINAL I LIKE A COMPANY THAT STEALS FRANCHISES BECAUSE THEY CAN'T HIRE ANY GOOD TALENT, AND CALLS THEMSELVES "INNOVATIVE." Good luck paying an xtra 300-500 bucks on a new motion control t.v. if you want to experience it. MORONS

I'd say its a tie between sony and microsoft unless Nintendo showed Monster Hunter Tri fotage...then they win

the disagree trolls are fun!

that confirence was just a surprise after a surprise for me. all the games just looked beautiful.

are people so blinded to see this. Microsoft proved themselves this 2009 when people had doubted them before e3.

Each console owner will be happy, put it that way. I don't think many people will have been disappointed with their console company's demonstrations and revelations.

its so funny how the uncharted 2 gameplay looks from the stream now that its up in 720 i came in my pants. Loved the moment where every fanboy went omg old trico trailer i was like seriously not sony there style to show old stuff and bam there we had it 30secs of gameplay pretty much. Then jacks jokes with hannah montana pretty epic i knew you would like that bundle. Then ofc motion controll which was just funny when the guy was busy with the huge sword. Great succes for sony here.

anyone who says sony should be ashamed of them selfs

Microsoft hands down.

i would have said sony won this years e3

but il give the edge to ms because of the great features to live and that motion thing was absolutely amazing

i just know Nintendo did the worse. Sony and Microsoft both had big conferences but i was more excited for Microsoft cause i own only a 360. If i owned a ps3 i might have been excited but i cant tell cause i don't own one. i think they both had strong showings both with exclusives. i didn't see a game on either that didn't look amazing. What i liked about the 360 motion sensing gameplay was the fact that u dont need a controller. ign is reporting that they used it to play burnout paradise and it worked so that is cool. The Sony motion controller worked in a very similar way and worked great as well. Both Sony and Microsoft pretty much destroyed the Wii with the motion sensing tech tho.

Sony won it here is another proof HEAVY RAIN E3 TRAILER !!

http://www.gamersyde.com/ne...

Seriously download in HD !! Looks astonishing !!

BTW girl from "The casting" is there !!

Gamers Won!

how is sony dying .....LOL

kojima slapped 360 fanboy's in the face with a spin off .. so they can STFU.

HE RATHER WORK WITH A PSP . THAN 360 .. ITS SAD REALLY....

Did anyone notice the loudest applause of all 3 conferences came during the Uncharted 2 gameplay, just Nathan looking out at the sprawl? Sony wins based on that alone. Ms and Nintendo pressers were full of awkward silences and courtesy laughs. Deal with it.

Gamers.

No arguments necessary.

God Of War was fantastic in all its full-on savage glory.
Uncharted to me is Tomb Raiders successor in the action/adventure department.
Haven't seen MAG or Mass Effect yet,I have high hopes for both but i'll take it with a pinch of salt until I hunt down a video.
Gran Turismo looked fantastic,but they really do have competition now with the brilliance of Forza.
Heavy Rain and Alan Wake,both interesting and great looking titles.
MGS Rising doesn't interest me nor does Final Fantasy,so I'll leave those blank and let the fans of the series brag about those.
Assassin's Creed looks brilliant,full stop.
If Resistance 3 was announced it would have been the icing on the cake for me with SONY's presentation,but I already knew that was slim to nil being announced at this E3 butluckily we have Ratchet and Clank to fill the Insomniac void until then.

E3 was pretty lame this year, to be honest. It had to be because of all the leaks before, though.

i got to say im not really surprised that pretty much everyone on N4G thinks Sony won... but to me it was the worse of all 3, certainly not bad, i was pretty good, but basically they didnt showed anything new, im not sure what new games you people are talking about, but the only new thing i saw for PS3 was a logo of a game(agent) and FF XXIV which is really great but once again, we know nothing about it, the rest, all games we had already seen, even the TRICO game, it was the same leaked footage from about a month ago, no real gameplay footage of GT after all this time?? thats lame.. and the motion controller, what can i say, it Wii Motion + but done with the camera and in REALLY early state, but owning a wii i can say im pretty exited for it, specially since it has a controller unlike Natal(which is awesome as well), so overall, as a PS3 conference it was boring, the same as microsoft conference, bunch of videos of games we already knew and nothing interesting on new games, on the PSP side, it was really great, it made me consider getting one.

As for Nintendo, i know no one here will ever admit it was a good conference (or while am at it, you will never admit anything good about nintendo) and in terms of new anouncements it was clearly the winner, new footage of Wii sports resort other games, New Super mario bros wii looks really fun, Golden Sun DS made my day, Galaxy 2 and Metroid Other M, i wasnt really anoyed that there was no Zelda because if they had shown it, it would have been a video that doesnt really show anything. So the only thing i missed was Pikmin 3, Sin and Punishment 2 and Kid Icarus, and S&P2 is on the floor so i still get to see it.

Overall: Nintendo followed closely by microsoft and in a close third Sony(since i dont have a PSP otherwise it would be 2nd). But all were great conferences with great games, which goes to show, THE ONLY LOSERS ARE THE FANBOYS WHO CANNOT ADMIT THE GOOD THINGS ABOUT THE OTHER CONSOLES, GREAT TIME TO HAVE MORE THAN 1 CONSOLE !!!!

You guys suck the joy out of gaming.

is the clear winner!!

Maybe the "big white innovation in gaming since 2005" console press yesterday or the 2006 Black "way too expensive" and "in over its head" console press today. Don't ask me though. I could have slept on this event and the outcome would still be the same. Bottom line : More exclusives from Sony.

It was fairly even between microsoft and sony. As a person with no real bias toward the two it seemed to me that microsoft had way more big games to show then ps3 but ps3 had the best and biggest quality in the games it showed. I know there is alot of fanboys who will disagree in moments but i think it was very even with each company doing better in a different part. 360 had so many exclusives it was flat out nuts... they were head and sholders above even nintendo. In terms of quantity nintendo and sony had about the same amount of showings but it was extremely clear which knew their audience the best. The answer was sony. If you look past your bias you'll see that sony had very few big exclusive offerings to show. they showed next to nothing in terms of homes innovation except that it still exists. They spent too much time on psp when ps3 should have been front and center. PSP go seems like a terrible idea.. almost as bad as natal.

In closing sony won but by a miniscule margin... in many ways i can say microsoft won by a similar margin. But i give sony the crown mostly because the last guardian was so beautiful i nearly wept and they showed a motion control demo that worked in the real world. While it still looked a tad weird it is undeniable that it did in fact work. Better then microsofts fantasy machine where turning around results in your body twisted like a pretzel on screen.. BAM!

It was a close one this year, Microsoft won last year by a landslide. But they just edged this one out this year. So MS won for the last few years now at E3.

Honestly I was impressed and excited for both Confs. I thought Microsoft was going to disappoint because they have been so quiet but they didn't, and this Year Sony Drops some serious bombs. In the end I win because I have all three consoles.

I thought Sony had the best showing this year.

They showed a ton of exclusives (everyone on this site fails to mention the White Knight Chronicles footage) and their tech demo was pretty impressive. I think its sad that both Microsoft's and Sony's motion sensing tech is more advanced than Nintendo's but I'm also not surprised.
The Rockstar and FF 14 announcements were pretty huge and the Last Gaurdian looked amazing. Uncharted 2, Ratchet and Clank, MAG, GT5, God of War 3, Modnation Racing, Heavy Rain, etc. Sony really brought the games and even showed the Joker exclusive DLC as well as mentioning that Lost Planet was on its way to PS3. I also like that Sony sticks to their word with the 10 year life cycle and enforces it.

I also thought Microsoft did a great job too. Was nice to see Alan Wake in motion and Splinter Cell looked great. Forza 3 looks good and Halo got some more attention. I like the non Master Cheif aspect. I also thought their motion sensing tec h was impressive even though it wasn't in real time like Sony's was running on the PS3 live. All in all a very good conference.

Nintendo....ugh. Mario....really? Metroid? WTF. They continue to dissapoint. They don't push the envelope. I feel like the last great nintendo system was teh SNES. I thought Nintendo's show stunk, 2 years in a row now.

Sony and MS were great, but I give SOny the edge.

When is a game bad because it isn't an exclusive. I have both systems and I thought that Microsoft had the better showing. I don't get into the who won crap. The reason why I think that Microsoft did well is because they are giving the people what they want.

Crackdown 2
Forza 3
Halo: ODST
Halo: Reach
SPlinter Cell: COnviction

Now I wish that there were new IP's but these games are going to sell in the millions. I bet you the Halo: ODST is going to sell more than anything the PS3 will offer this year or next. I mean you fanboys talk about Team Ico etc and this game and that game but alot of SOny's games dont appeal to anyone outside of the hardcore fanboy base. I mean Killzone 2, Resistance 2, Motorstorm 2, Little Big Planet, Uncharted are not popular games with the masses hence the mediocre sales for each of the games. Now Sony does have an impressive lineup but in a way they are cutting their own throats. Releasing those games in the same time frame is stupid (just like releasing Resistance 2 and Killzone 2 within months of each other.

Microsoft is in cruise control. Third party titles sell more on the 360. Microsoft has Xbox Live. The 360 is the premiere HD gaming system. Sales don't lie. That is the bottom line. Does the Ps3 have superior graphics Hell yes!! DO they have good game Hell yes! But right now the game belongs to Microsoft. Accept it, refuse it but it is the truth.

Oh wait not really because I'm going to be broke damn.
So many games so little time err money lol.

I think both Sony and M$ does a great performance' no doubt about it.

"What the fu<k did we win? Everyday I look in mailbox for my O.J. prize, nuthin!" C.Rock

Just replace 'O.J.' with your corporation of choice.