All Channels
Popular
280°

Why So Much Hate for Resident Evil 5?

Resident Evil 5 is one of the biggest games of 2009. At the same time, the game is getting plenty of criticism well before its release.

Read Full Story >>
associatedcontent.com
I_LOVE_MYSELF6262d ago

I love it... Best game so far this year in my opinion... Possibly will be my GOTY... Shame people complain its too much like Resi4 when games like Gears2 and God of War2 dont get people complaining that they are similar to their previous installments...

dantesparda6261d ago

Because of the controls!!! Plain, pure and simple! If youse notice all the complaining came in as soon as people played the demo. Before that, nobody was complaining. Look the game looks good both graphically and "contently" (i know, i know, i just made that up). And while i know as bad as the controls feel (the inability to walk and shoot is what does it for me), you will get used to them like everybody did with RE4. But these controls just dont cut it anymore in this day and age.

BkaY6261d ago

currently im on my 3rd playthrough and 2 of my mates are on their 4th..

ppl who complain about the controls.... have u even played re4.....

re4 got 9.2 or 9.4 (i dont remember) from ign and lots of other sites ... did someone complained about the controls back then... i dont remember that... i just dont understand tht why ppl want everything to be played as COD or gears.... i mean whas up with that...

game is great...

one tip.. start playing on easy mode.... and im pretty sure once u finish the game... u will be moving like pro... its just getting used to the controls thts all.....

when i played the demo... controls felt soooooooooo stiff and heavy..
now its like smooth as butter... 1hr ago i was playing online coop... and tht my friend is real fun...

just give a go.... if you like it then fine... if dont then dont buy it, rent it or whatever... im a diehard fan of re series... playing it from re1...

keep on gaming
peace

ParanoidMonkey6261d ago

IGN actually gave the initial GameCube release of RE4 a 9.8

Just sayin'.

6261d ago
theKiller6261d ago (Edited 6261d ago )

people actually needs to play the games before judging them!!! we r taking the media words for granted!!!!

media at some times will try to put down a big game and at other times will try to put up a small/nothing special game!!! it all depends on if that specific publisher is paying well for advertising or not!!!

gaming reviews is becoming a business!! its not innocent industry any more!!! games these days have extreme violent, sex, and all kind of bad things!!!

so when it comes to game reviews or media on gaming expect something similar to world conflicts on specific wars or problems!!

if u ask a CNN reporter about afghanistan then u will get the american point of view of that country and if u ask a taliban on his country u will hear a complete different story!! usually more accurate!!

Cwalat6261d ago

Every fan of the series will love it,
every newcomer will probably say: "jeez i hate the controls"

In reality, everthing today doesn't need to standard and copy of other games.

I aprreciate the fact that they kept SOMETHING atleast that screams Resident Evil, although i'm pretty upset with the fact that the Horror is completely gone in this one.

....... The general reason why people are upset with RE5 is that, since they've ditched horror alot of people were expecting the game to be nothing but Action and zero tactics. The controls made it more tactical than action and alot of people were aggrivated by this.

"uuh sh****t i cant run while i'm aiming W*T*F?!"

Well, people need to pull their heads outta their a**ses because in reality, NO ONE RUNS AND GUNS.

maybe someone who wishes for an early death, but in reality... nothing is like COD or Gears... soldiers don't even run and gun during war...

Yes it's a game, but all games cant be the same... what a boring industry this would've been.

To end my comment,

RE fans - won't mind

New buyers - W*TF* i can't ru`n and gun?!

Jager6261d ago

"Why So Much Hate for Resident Evil 5?"

The answer is simple ... it's multiplat, that's why the hate. Same thing happend with GTA4.

If Resident Evil 5 and GTA4 was exclusive to one console, then it would be praised to the heavens.... SIMPLE AS THAT."

So the media is biased against multiplats? Ya.. No. Resident Evil 4 was Multiplat, didnt stop it from getting good reviews.

GTA4 is multiplat, one of the highest rated games this gen. Pat GTAs had been Multiplat (PC versions).

Your logic is flawed. Fermcr, get off the fanboy boat before you type.

Perjoss6261d ago

I love it too, but i have to say that if it were not for the '180 turn' move I'd probably find it too annoying to play. Only problem I have with it is its not scary at all, and seriously lacks atmosphere compared to older RE games, although I have only played the first few levels, maybe it gets darker and more gloomy later on?. I just think its really hard to make a scary game that is set in broad daylight. Being low on ammo pretty much all the time makes it tense but it does not really make it scary, just adds a sense of panic. It also does not help that you have a partner now. Still a great game though.

Making a comparison to a game like Fallout 3, all the time you are outdoors its pretty much a normal exploration game, but once you go underground and light levels drop a lot, its gets very atmospheric and creepy in places. Not the best example of a scary game, just making a note of the outdoors and daylight setting compared to indoors and dark/gloomy areas.

s8anicslayer6261d ago

I know many people including myself who feel that RE 5 is better then RE 4, overall it's a solid game with superb visuals

divideby06261d ago

should not even be on the list of GOTY contenders...
the controls are last gen, the atmosphere is killed by loading and inventory access..
game is barely worthy of a 8.
I am not saying its not fun, just cant come close to competing with games of 09

6261d ago
poopface16261d ago (Edited 6261d ago )

main problem is you cant just press RT or R1(?) to shoot without having to take aim. I would like walking and shooting but I dont think its necessary if he could just shoot without aiming. This is most noticeable with the shotgun. But if capcom did make these changes than they can make Re 6 a little more challenging I hope.

Im only on normal but it seems too easy. Its like capcom and the enemies know how crappy the shooting system is so they let you get away. All you have to do is run forward to survive anything in the game.

Other than that its great. And I havent even tried co-op yet. I dont mind games with challenging controls cause it makes it different. The inventory really brings back my re2 memories.

Looks great and the loads are really short. So short that I usualy cant read the RE history when its loading . Even when it like 2 lines only. And yes, I can read.

Sarcasm6261d ago (Edited 6261d ago )

@Jager

That's the stupidest conclusion i've ever seen.

Even if it was exclusive to one platform, that doesn't change the control scheme one tiny bit. People will still hate the control scheme.

Proof?

Killzone 2. Hyped to the heavens.

Controls were sluggish, some people HATED it (the controls). Copies were returned, blood was shed in the forums, and the community was split into two.

Although of course people see it as GOTY just like how people think RE5 is GOTY.

It's all personal opinions.

ThanatosDMC6261d ago

Why would you play on easy mode first? That, for me, messes up how the game should be played. Then your second play through will just be a breeze since you know everything you need to do and probably have upgraded guns and whatever else.

LastDance6261d ago

pffft, I think its length, melee controls and AI are way more reason to complain about than movement controls.

cayal6261d ago

"The answer is simple ... it's multiplat, that's why the hate. Same thing happend with GTA4.

If Resident Evil 5 and GTA4 was exclusive to one console, then it would be praised to the heavens.... SIMPLE AS THAT."

Your logic fails, fanboy.

Resident Evil 4 was a Gamecube game before PS2. People still loved it.
GTA-San Andreas went to Xbox. People still loved it.

No one suddenly said San Andreas was crap once it was released on Xbox or that Resident Evil 4 was suddenly awesome because it was released on PS2 awhile after the GC version.

As for GTAIV, it was simply over-rated IMO.
Resident Evil 5 is under-rated IMO. I loved it.

Tapewurm6261d ago

The controls on this game are perfectly fine. Well suited for the game. And just for the record the actual finished game has different default controls than the demo and the final games default controls are just fine. Buy the game and enjoy it... it is simply amazing to play.... great story, great graphics, great game.

vickers5006261d ago

"But these controls just dont cut it anymore in this day and age."

That only applies to the people who like playing the same thing over and over again, not wanting anything different.

dantesparda6260d ago (Edited 6260d ago )

"That only applies to the people who like playing the same thing over and over again, not wanting anything different."

Do you even realize what you've just said? RE5 basically has the same controls as RE4, so therefore that means that you are playing the same thing over and over again and not wanting anything different.

And to anyone that thinks im some kind of RE noobie, I've been playing RE since the 1st one, and loved part 4 and thought it was one of the best games EVER! but i cannot stand the controls anymore, PERIOD! I was really looking forward to this game until i played it and just cant stand controls anymore.

And to the retard fermr, if you think that there is something wrong with KZ2s controls but not this game's, then you just might be a 360 fanboy. And dont call other people "fanboys" when you're obviously a 360 fanboy yourself. And p.s. i own the 360

+ Show (16) more repliesLast reply 6260d ago
TomBailey6262d ago

...because you do not buy the game complete, capcom want to ripoff you selling some download content. I Miss The good ol' days of the Super NES, Saga Genesis when you pay for the game,you pay for the whole game.

I_LOVE_MYSELF6262d ago

okay a little bit of content is missing that should of been there... I admit... Crapcom are pissing me off with this DLC crap... BUT what you get on the disc fully justifies the asking price...

Lets face it Resi5 is not a game like Motorstorm where it really is half a game on the disc and buy the rest with dlc...

TomBailey6262d ago (Edited 6262d ago )

...Why you justify Capcom? You pay $60.00 for a game and is missing content? No Way Amigo. This is a Ripoff by capcom and other companies. That is why people pirate games. Capcom, if you give me the DLC Free, I will buy the game.

I_LOVE_MYSELF6262d ago (Edited 6262d ago )

How did I justify Capcom? ... Im saying the amount of content on the disc is worth the asking price... Forget about DLC a second... Resident Evil 5's content is worthy of the asking price... Decent length campaign, online leaderboards, coop, unlockables, extra mode and replay value for the stuff you missed... It IS worth the money in my opinion...

The fact they are taking advantage of DLC sucks but I dont have to worry about that because I am happy with what I paid for already... Im not gonna buy the DLC... Im in no way justifying DLC... Im just saying im happy with Resi5 the way it is and its worth every penny in its current form

Montrealien6261d ago

Tom Bailey would need to actually play the game instead of just b**ching against the man.

I bought this great game and it was worth every penny. If I ever decide to get VS mode or not, I'm sure it will be worth the 5$. But the fact of the mater is, what you buy for 60$ is worth 60$.

II Necroplasm II6261d ago (Edited 6261d ago )

Everyone knows that mostly PS3 fanboys is the main people to diss it. for some odd reason :/

Jager6261d ago

Really? Only PS3 fans?

90 MS Xbox World
90 Official Xbox Magazine
85 Team Xbox
81 Xbox World 360 Magazine UK
80 X360 Magazine UK
80 Official Xbox Magazine UK

And then:

100 Playstation: The Official Magazine (US)
80 TotalPlayStation
80 Playstation Official Magazine UK
79 PSX Extreme

Seems roughly even to me.

Lowest scores for RE5 come from :

70 Edge
60 G4
70 Gamer.nl
70 Teletext
73 Computer and video games
75 1UP

Funny how you claim that its PS3 sites / fans who hate the game, yet in reality its PS3 sites that rated it higher.

Montrealien6261d ago (Edited 6261d ago )

I dont think he was refering to reviews, more like the general bickering on comments sections and forums.

Either way its useless remark though, the people that hate on the game dont like Resident Evil and probably wont get it and where never planning on getting it. And even though people that are "hating" on it might seem vocal, there are clearly part of the minority. 90% of gamers never come to places like this to argue or bicker anyways, they just buy games they like and enjoy them.

PirateThom6261d ago (Edited 6261d ago )

The odd thing is, I loved Resident Evil up until RE3 (and even Code: Veronica if we go out of cannon). I didn't play 4 until the Wii and they totally just lost me with it, it's a good action game, but I play Resident Evil because it's survival horror not just to shoot things with practically unlimited ammmo.

cayal6261d ago

While I miss the survival horror aspect of it. RE4 and RE5 are fantastic additions to the series.

+ Show (6) more repliesLast reply 6261d ago
chidori6666261d ago

imo... because of r5 not have nothing new or spectacular and lost all survival horror

Nelson M6261d ago

And i thought it was a Mighty Fine Game
Some really Good Locations
Good Campaign length
Fantastic Graphics
Some Great Cut Scenes
I know it not a Huge Step forward from Resi 4
But Yeah i do feel the Next one needs to make Bigger steps towards this Gen

mistajeff6261d ago

Aside from the DLC thing (which is bullshit on Capcom's part) and the racism thing (which is bullshit on EVERYONE'S part), I think it's getting a lot of bad press because it didn't really innovate. Yeah, co-op stirred up the Resident Evil formula, but the gaming press (including the myriad of commenters who read and post) is so thirsty for innovation that it tends to overlook the most crucial factor: is the game fun?
Call it archaic, backwards, whatever.. but is it fun? Hell yes. It's an appropriate extension of their formula in the transition to the new generation of consoles. Remember Code Veronica? Some people loved it, some people called it atrocious and unplayable because it used the PS1 camera/control scheme. But it was an appropriate extension of what they already had, and it latched them into a new generation of hardware. Resi 4 came years later. You can expect the next Resident Evil to innovate the formula, but I didn't see anything wrong with this one. You have people like Adam Sessler b!tching that it's not as innovative as Bioshock or Mass Effect, yet neither of these games are really innovative at all if you've played System Shock 1 or 2 or Knights of the Old Republic or Jade Empire, merely extensions of the formulas they had already established (I'm really about this 'extension of formula' phrase today, jesus). But do we really want fun to be sacrificed in the name of innovation? Take Mirror's Edge, which is hailed as last year's flagship 'innovator.' A first person game without guns, GASP! People said that about Myst, too. I thought Mirror's Edge was so linear that the game was crippled. In one level, I died a good number of times trying to hop over a 7-foot gap (after having leaped 20 feet horizontally over a street), only to realize that the devs wanted me to wall-run and not jump. Maybe that should've been more obvious to me than it was, but why the hell couldn't I jump over the gap when it's not only within Faith's acrobatic ability, but MINE as well? There's so little freedom within the gameplay that, at least for me, it just sucked all the fun right out of it. "Next-gen," whatever, I'd rather play an HD version of any game from the last 8000 console generations than suffer through that type of "innovation."
That's my opinion, yes, obviously a lot of people liked Mirror's Edge, I'm just using this to illustrate the ill effects of innovation simply for the sake of innovation. I definitely don't believe that RE5 innovates in any way, but it carries infinitely more substance than a lot of games today that are focused solely on "innovation."
Innovation is best in small chunks than giant steps at a time, otherwise it tends to crumble under its own weight. Take COD4, for example. Play the single-player and look at the gameplay alone and by itself. Absolutely nothing new, nothing innovative. It's more or less COD2 in the middle east in the 2000's. But the multiplayer introduced a class and perk system that was hailed as innovative. It's not a huge change, really, and doesn't have a dramatic impact on the core gameplay, but it was so perfectly innovative that people are still picking COD4 over a ton of shooters that have come out since.
That was full of tangents, but hopefully I got my point across somewhere in there.

BkaY6261d ago

u got tht right...

peace

Perjoss6261d ago

screw the racism part, I've played games where i've killed only white people from start to finish and I never felt like my 'race' was being treated unfairly.

I think Capcom listened to all the noise people made because when I compare trailers and early demo movies I see mainly black people but in the full game they added a lot of other races in there too. But now it just feels wrong, you are clearly walking around some shanty towns in africa and you would expect to see 99% black people walking around.

Or perhaps I'm totally wrong, after all I have never been to a place like that myself, only speaking from what I've seen in movies and documentaries about the rougher places in Africa.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 6261d ago
Show all comments (101)
50°

Resident Evil, Resident Evil 2 and Resident Evil 3 Now Available on Steam

Capcom has announced and released the original Resident Evil, Resident Evil 2 and Resident Evil 3 on Steam.

Read Full Story >>
nettosgameroom.com
on_line_forever32d ago

The best resident evil games forever

40°

The UK Has Gone Mad for Resident Evil After the Huge Success of Requiem on PS5

Capcom recently released Resident Evil Requiem, and it's been so successful that it's seemingly dragging along every other Resi game with it.

That's certainly true in the UK; the latest physical retail charts have come in, and the top 10 includes five Resident Evil games across all platforms.

Read Full Story >>
pushsquare.com
Smellsforfree57d ago

Well, they are all a lot of fun.

40°

Capcom Removes Enigma DRM From The PC Version OF Resident Evil 4 Remake

Capcom has removed the recently added Enigma DRM from the PC version of its survival horror game, Resident Evil 4 remake.

Read Full Story >>
twistedvoxel.com