100°

The Game Awards, Like Every Awards Show, Has A Problem

Shaz from PS: "The recently announced nominees for The Game Awards bring to light an ongoing issue with the awards show."

Read Full Story >>
pixel-swish.com
Garethvk56d ago (Edited 56d ago )

Politics and backroom wheeling and dealing are common for many awards. The lobbying, gifts, parties, campaigns with lavish spending, etc for films and television is a massive undertaking. Movie awards often come down to who has spent the most on the campaigns. Warner Bros reportedly spent millions to lobby for Fury Road as an example. One report said an Oscar win could involve 4-6 million or more in campaigns per major category.

--Onilink--56d ago

If anything, I’d say the problem with the Game Awards is entirely in the opposite direction. The way the jury pool is handled means it is waaaaaay too much of an unfiltered popularity contest, which clearly shows in games being in wrong categories or ones that are clearly missing from them.

The jury pool is 100+ media outlets, There are very little to no restrictions on what they submit. Each media outlet has their own method for deciding internally what they propose. And the game awards simply tabulates and aggregates all the lists they get.

There are no discussions between the jurors, no justification they need to provide for their proposals, no visibility into how each voted (not that I think its necessary, and their own internal proposals probably go through a similar process for employees to choose what the outlet submits, etc.

The idea of backroom dealings or collusion doesn’t make much sense, because they would need to do it with 100+ outlets, the idea that something like that wouldn’t have spread out at some point is very unlikely. If it were a small jury pool of specific individuals, then it is something much more likely.

If the Game Awards wants to be taken seriously as an award show(which I don’t think they care about it that much so neither should we), they probably should start putting a lot more restrictions for the jurors (guarantees that they have played the games, discussions among them, maybe even limit the jury pool size, etc)

victorMaje56d ago

Until game awards have categories like best physics, best new mechanic, best enemy/NPC AI, best level design I cannot take them seriously…

SimpleDad56d ago

That's a bit much... Let's start by nominating action games in the action category, and indie games in the indie category... and then, maybe consider games that people played and enjoyed.

UnbreakableAlex56d ago

Most intelligent comment I’ve read all day.

Levii_9256d ago

Yeah i agree with what is said in the article, Yotei shouldn’t be anywhere near in those high categories but then again so does DK Bananza..

The guy in the article says Bananza should be in the best game direction category for this and that etc but here i am thinking how the f does a game that has awful framerate, obnoxious blabbing characters, insufferable cringe sidekick character that says weird uncomortable things that you can’t mute, derivative world design that’s very Mario Odyssey underneath, a very disappointing end game with disappointing challenges, a paid dlc nostalgia world that only 8 years ago would have been in the main game (imagine if Mushroom Kindom in Odyssey was paid dlc and cost $19.99), only 4 DK country nostalgia levels (only 4?? Come on man) how does a game like that deserve to be anywhere near those big categories? So all this “award shows have a problem” thing always comes down to people being pissed or disappoined that a game they liked isn’t nominated or didn’t win something or in my case here with my little rant a game did get nominated for several things but does not deserve it IMO.

So politics and some sort of bias will always be involved so instead of always complaining we should just be grateful that games that deserve to be there, games made with pure passion and creativity like BG3, Astro Bot, E33, Silksong are there being nominated and wining.

P_Bomb56d ago

Personally, I think I brewed one Saviour Schnapps too many in GOTY nominee KCD2. Couldn’t finish it. The sim life, man. I already have one thankless job, lol! 🤣

30°

The Epic Games Store Has a Free Double Dose of Styx

The Epic Games Store is giving away two Styx games this week.

Read Full Story >>
terminalgamer.com
30°

GDC Festival of Gaming announces Luminaries Speaker Series

The new offering is geared towards 'senior decision-makers' across the industry.

Read Full Story >>
gamedeveloper.com
50°

Sony may have blocked 4th largest publisher on PS Store, targeting shovelware PS4/PS5 games

PlayStation Store shoppers are seeing fewer undesirable search results. ThiGamesDE, a major publisher of shovelware like The Jumping Spaghetti, no longer appears on the marketplace. The games are inexpensive, duplicate versions of other titles that appeal to trophy hunters.

Read Full Story >>
notebookcheck.net
HumanChimney1d 11h ago

Good! .....and no more awfully boring simulators as well please!

galgor1d 1h ago

You didn't see the group of simulator games that just launched then, eh?

Eonjay1d 7h ago

Next story will be about how Sony is hurting gamers by blocking trash games.

lodossrage22h ago

....don't give them ideas.....

gold_drake1d 6h ago

dude who made those games definitely made bank with them tho.

im glad they're gone tho

jznrpg1d 4h ago

I hate those trophy whore games so good.

DivineHand1251d 4h ago

Too bad for the trophy hunters, but this action is necessary.

The existence of these games for the sole purpose of helping people pad their trophy list cheapens the experience.

It also clutters the store with garbage games.

jambola19h ago

I wouldn't even care if you could just filter them
but I like sorting by newest to oldest to see new games and this really just ruins it

Show all comments (12)