oh good grief, here we go again...
Fanboy 1: OMG, t3h button on t3h 360 version looks better! lawlz
Fanboy 2: STFU j00 n00b, ps3 version looks better! gtfo f@99ot!

The 360 version blew the PS3 version away!

In before the flames!

j/k

Both are dope! This is the new Bioshock! I can't wait to get my hands on it now.

its only in 720p because that all the ps3 version does....720p like LBP 720p...i can name 27 games easily that are only in 720p on ps3....including resistance uncharted and soul caliber....full HD gaming my a$$

Waiting for those Eagle Eye 360 fans who notices every tiny pixel difference, but then magically cant tell the difference between Blu-Ray and DVD.

I thought they were both scary!

the 360 version got this one.. but not by much..

I would say very close. looking at around 1.50, the guy running down the corridor looked a little better on the PS3.

I just had a heart attack. that game sure has some shock value. How am I going to survive.

i want to see a comparison of that. they both looked the same just one was brighter then the other but your tv can fix that.

On the topic of the actual game, it is actually pretty scary. Was playing it earlier with my 5.1 head set on with the volume up pretty loud. And god, I've never actually jumped from a game before. Especially those friggin' ones that looked dead but aren't.

EA has a hit on their hands.

Watch the cut scene really carefully... the monitor in the center of the screen shows way more detail on the Xbox 360 than the PS3. There's also visible more aliasing issue on the PS3.

I got the PS3 version and will surely enjoy this game later tonight.

to me this is one of the best comparisons ever, there's really no differences other than brightness an darkness which can be adjusted by the TV. but now come on guys lets be honest here. why games ported FROM the PS3 to the 360 looks IDENTICAL but games ported FROM the 360 to the PS3 looks an runs like crap on the PS3, an I don't wanna hear the weaker 360 crap response either!!

360=PS3
PS3-360
360>PS3

From what I can see, 360 looks better.. but doesn't surprise me with multiplatform games.

Look how washed the ps3 looks :(

lol, I thought these comparison videos ended months ago?

Dead space looks awesome, I'm really going to have to add it to my list.

no surprise that the 360 version looks better.

It looks like they're comparing "High Dynamic Range Rendering" (HDR Rendering) compared to no HDR Rendering on the TV consoles.

HDR Rendering (PS3) vs. No HDR Rendering (360)

HDR Rendering makes bright scenery brighter and dark scenery darker while maintaining detail throughout. Whether that is really the case can be debated, but that's what it looks like every time when developers make PlayStation 3 games properly.

Everybody knows it will look better on the PC....

the wii version looked the best

The 360 version won clearly and why?

I say it in PS3tard words:

a halfed price console with outdated DVD9 looks the same as the 2 times faster and best console of the world - PS3.

PS3 got owned once again after MGS4 which will fit on max 2 DVD9.. cause nobody needs a 22Gb 7.1 TRUE HD sound and MGS4 had 33GB in use.. so 11GB will fit compressed.

bye PS3 midgets

Someone is always hatin on da ps3 and its capibilities. Just leave it along its a better system hands down we just received a massive update 2.50 as 4 the 360 its still the same old ishh.. Home is on da way and so is rfom2. Socom is out as of yesterday and lbp is comin also what does 360 have nothing... o wait tears of whores only 1 exclusive damn microlost....

Although I really don't see the significance of these comparison videos. I mean really what comes of them? I'm not gonna buy a 360 or PS3 just because it may look better there.
Anyways...
I can actually say that the PS3 version looks noticeably better. It has a richer feel to it. Could be the contrast though. Funny how people above say the PS3 version looks washed out...it actually appears to be the 360 version that is slightly washed out. Anyways this game is a must buy in my book on whatever system you may own.

-Black

ps3 version looks the best. although the video shows tiny difference, no wonder in this bad quality.

both look awesome.
between this and socom i should be busy till next weeks 3 games come out.

wtf am i doing hahahaaa.......

edit:

haha ali i have no idea, i guess some people just are bubble hungry, which i cant blame them. they taste good.

only the 360 game and console are cheaper, which equals better value...

Heeeere we go again.

why do people have to be fanboys i was and now i am getting a 360 for gears 2 i missed out on gears one and i will not miss out on gears 2 this time so i am getting a 360.
so people just play the dam game.
both the 360 and PS3 have good games.
so stop your dam fighting and play the dam games.
and the PS3 Dead Space is a little darker that is all its nothing much.
so pick one and buy it who cares if you like the 360 buy it for it and if you like the PS3 buy it for it does not matter which one you get. they are the same game.

look at that

PS3 version looks good

im buying it

i didnt even look at the video

you know why?
because i have a 1080p and i know it will look awesome....

well deadspace main platform was ps3 so obviously the ps3 version is the better version but only by a tiny bit. its stupid to think that the console that isnt the lead platform will look better because why the hell would that happen unless obviously the game had extra dev time. basically ps3 lead platforms are better than 360s and vice versa. so everyone shut up and just enjoy the game.

.....from now on i want the PS3 to be the lead platform for all multiplatform games. Its a better way of doing things and the end results seem to be a lot better as well for everyone, not just PS3 owners but for 360 owners too. This game looks identical on both consoles and looks fantastic as well. Happy times ahead.

It has been said time and again, that the multi platform games will look better if the PS3 is made the lead platform, and then optimising the game for each platforms strengths, allowing for a fanastic end result. This shows in Dead Space, which seems to be an incredible game regardless of platform.

The PS3 does look a little nicer but I think the brightness on 360 has been jacked up, the graphics are as near as matters identical

but you cant really judge by a video... ONLY MY OPINION the 360 version looks a little bit washed out compared to the ps3 version also in the scene where the alien attacks the other guys in the room there are more sparks made on the ps3 version. still these are MINOR differences and both games are going to be near identical

The colors on the PS3 are richer than the 360 from what they claim to be each versions.

Since the PS3 almost never has the deeper colors I have to guess they labeled the clips wrong.

Regardless, the version they say is the PS3 version looks better overall because it is more solid.

I'm just wondering why you need Money in this dead Space ship.... If all you own is a PS3 then PS3 is Better, If all you own is an Xbox then Xbox is Better.. I'm about 20mins in on xbox it pretty good game... The Money thing though..hmm???

Both look very good. I can't add anything that hasn't been argued already. I purchased the 360 version personally but either will suffice. The gameplay looks pretty good and scary too. Will gladly spend the night with this baby.

...with all these comparisons that if I play around with the TV settings a little I can make one look better than the other very easily.

If you have an HDTV you know what I'm talking about so these comparisons are just pointless. The only thing that we can look at in a comparison like this is the framerate.

Argueing about colors and shadows is meaningless.

360 version looks washed out and the lighting is definately not as good as the PS3 version

Comparisons are lame.

PS3 was the lead

and you know why?

because games dont suffer from porting if you go from PS3>360

good for us real gamers

I don't even need to watch the video to know who won. Droids are saying it looks the same, and xbots say it looks better. The only time droids ever say "it looks the same" is when it's clearly in favor of the 360, they do it with every compairison. Or they will say "lazy devs" or "it's UE3" or some other engine that doesn't port well to the PS3, or they will blame the site as being "pro xbox". This is a game that lead on the PS3 and look... what a stiff kick in the nuts.

If you want to see which one is better looking, why don't you take a look at the main character's space suit. The PS3 version shows better detail. Not to mention the game is darker and more detailed in general on the ps3.

All I'm gonna say is it really shows the effort EA put into this game. Things turned out much better when you gave both systems EQUAL treatment.

So while the usual suspect 360 fanboys whine and the usual ps3 fanboys whine, I'll be getting the one that I PERSONALLY think is better. Which is the PS3 version. Have fun with your comparison videos and internet rants :)

in almost 2 years the ps3 is just NOW FINALLY getting on PAR WITH 360.old excuse from the ps3 fanboys was "if ps3 was lead platform it would be better than 360 version" you ALL just GOT OWNED, ILL SERVE YOU GUYS THE CROW. now ps3 fanboys say "it looks the same"- FINALLY IT DOES. thing is i can buy a 360 that can run this game for HALF of what the ps3 still costs TODAY, and i still get access to the better ONLINE! no EXCUSES PS3 FANBOYS/GIRLS PS3 SHOULD'VE BEEN THE BETTER VERSION IT ISNT AGAIN!!! now how would ya'll like ya crow served??

wow this is a pleasant surprise, same resolution, same AA, just brightness differences.I remember for a long time games looked more bright on PS3, now they look brighter on 360, weird.

Really the same, just need to tweak brightness on 360.

y doint they never do 360 vs ps3 vs pc?

looked alot better and more stuff happening on the screen at once. Look at the beginning at the asteroid..the sun gleam even looiked more brighter.

PS3 looks better. This just confirms that lead platform looks better and port looks worse all the time. It has nothing to do with the powah of the consoles.

here we go again. i'm not even gonna watch this. i just think that gamers need to stop with this nonsense. they came out in both consoles ? great everybody is a winner then

Beside this ridiculous comparison the game feels really terrifying.
That's cool! I would like to play it now!

they both look great but i have to say that the ps3 version is a little bit sharper and has better smoke effects ...
can't wait.

Everything looks the same except brightness difference. In this case it just results in what APPEARS TO BE, but isn't, better lighting on the PS3 since lighting always shows better in darker games. This is also a good thing in this case since it's a survival horror game and darkness is good.

PS3 verson is darkeer, ALOT darker, it makes a difference in parts of the game, a 2 min video wont help with games like this, SC 4, Fifa 09 something like those two games year, but not a game like Dead Space.

I aint gonna lie by saying I don't favor any console because I do (ps3 for now). I always admit when the 360 has the edge because i'm not blinded by ignorance. they both look good to me, so enjoy you fools.

no surprise it looks and runs better on 360.

so much for PS3 being "lead" LOL. all that means is they made sure not to make the 360 version look TOO good to run on GARBAGEstation .3 first. lol. thanks, droids. thanks for dumbing our game down.

poooooor ps3 :(

I'm just going to say for all you fan boys (PS3 or Xbox) Both games look awesome and the only difference is the slight lighting effects, but who's to say which one is the best no one ever plays the games side by side and when your playing the PS3 version or the Xbox version you'll be too busy craping your selves to notice or care.
People Like different things respect each others opinions and get on with your lonely lives.

I think your confused.

The PS3 has the better version and also has the better version of mirrors edge.

E.A has recently stated that they've got used to the ps3 and now understand where it's power is.

i.e All these companies are starting to put the spu's to work.

HDR lighting on ps3 is 128bit.

It's 64bit on 360.

It's the same thing that ati did with earlier cards.

Nvidia fx cards did higher range quality wise, but lost fps.

Ati did lower quality but with higher fps.

But when you use cell properly, there is no frame loss.

The ps3 version of this game has better lighting.

lol

This footage was captured from a capture card in a PC, not from a TV. A TV does not get involved with direct feed capture, and therefore no TV settings would alter anything.

PS3!

haha! lets argue over 720p resolution! im be playing it at a much better rez on my PC. u kids argue. ill play the superior version.

There the same except the brightness is down on the ps3 version. Ive downloaded vids on my ps3 and 360 and on my tv there are exactly the same. Stop tyring to find something thats not there and just enjoy the fact EA made a great game thats identical on both formats.

After looking at that video I am glad I own a 360 this gen.

too immersed in the video to even notice any differences.

That ..thing that was playing dead, actually made me jump.

They both look like crap. I guess this is what we can expect from having the PS3 the lead platform.

Lame, now we all suffer.

(i just wanted to be different)

20p ps3 titles..so far....alot

soul caliber
tiger woods 09
silent hill
vampire rain
fracture
nba live 09
star wars the force
madden
mercenaries 2
devil may cry 4
timeshift
motorstorm
overlord
burnout
haze
resistance
grid
guitar hero 3
guitar hero aerosmith
army of 2
battlefield bad company
turok
uncharted
unreal 3
ratchet and clank
armored core
fear

....i mean come time to step up

i love to see my tv say 1080p.....but i hate seeing it flicker to 720p when i put in a game...i wonder how long that will go on for...i mean freakin LBP is in 720p

looks pretty cool.

I think I will pick this one up soon. In fact, I think I will buy three of them - one each for my PS3, Xbox360, and PPC (I like to call my PC the "Power PC" because it makes me feel more masculine).

Man, I am SO not a fanboy.

A little OT, but, DYN that one's level of inclination towards obsessive behavior like "fanboyism" is a strong indicator of having no life? It's just a scientific hypothesis at this point, but the evidence is really mounting here on N4G.

Back OT. Yeah, cool looking game.

I originally intended to get this on 360 but controller preference and trophies has me getting the PS3 version. I also prefer the darker tones of the PS3 version even if it is something I never would have noticed before.

I also vow never to wander into the open zone again the sh!t being spewed in there from both parties is actually irritating me.

WHat I've noticed:

Everyone agreeing it looks the same are in the gamer zone, all the 360 fanboys claiming the 360 version looks better are in the Open Zone.

Coincidence?

Why 720p? It's written behind that the game can output in 1080p (PS3 version). I'm sure 360 version too can do 1080p, why 720?

on both consoles. Any minute differences are caused by the tv and are negligible. EA is regaining some respect, I'm sure.

the ps3 looked like it had better lighting though. anybody agree?

the PS360 vid is the best :P

both look the same i could just ajust my hdtv if i want it lighter or darker.

I own both systems and I will be purchasing this game for the ps3.

Both of them look great so it really doesn't matter. Or does it?

PS3 version seems to have the better colors and contrast. Just like all of these stupid comparisons, the differences are so minimal only losers care.

360 lead = ps3 can't keep up with 360.
ps3 lead = identical to 360 version.

still think ps3 is a more powerful gaming system ?

Seems to me like the PS3 had a bit more color but that's all I could tell.

seriously? its the ps3 version this time round, good job devs. Its most apparent in the scene where he runs away, go on take your fanboy glasses off and step up to the plate.

Very Nice , very little difference slight edge to PS3 for blacks however just lower your brightness =)

first time i can say its clear ps3 has better grahpics on a multiplat, and its not even overall grahpics its just the lighting effects look alot cripser on the ps3 rest seems the same.

i just got the game today and all i have to say is that it could be GOTY.it is that damm good.i have a 52 lcd shape aquos with hdmi and a home theather that would knock your face off.and it is more scary then RE4.PLAY B3YOND waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay B3YOND!!!

look at the blacks on the 360, the shadowing, everyhtign is brighter and washed out, takes away from teh mood they are trying to do. I knew the second the video started that the fist image they showed was the 360 version before they even told you which console was which. the AA seems to be worse on the 360. REgardless at this poitn EA is gonan make both version look exactly alike, they are using the exact same assets for both, the only thing the systems will do different is play stuff at a smoother frame rate. thast what you are gonan get from multiplat games. the systems will show there difference for exclusive games.

if a multiplat game looks different on eitehr system its a developer problem not teh hardware. Do you really think eather microsoft or Sony would let them make a inferior version of a multiplat game .

Anybody seen these pics yet?

its good for a change to see the ps3 version be the one where the lighting looks better, all u have to do is adjust the contrast for them to look equal tho

huh...stop cussing...its the same thing...sadly i have to admit it, for the first time, its the same thing...DONT REPLY ON MY COMMENT, UNLESS U WANT TO PROVE TO ME BY GIVING ME UR EYEZ.

Xbox360 game looks a bit better, It's the shadows and light effects that does it. Also the AA looks a bit better at the beginning of the video.

Some of you people really need to get your eyes checked out or better monitors. Dead Space looks better on the PS3. It looks sharper and more crisp. The PS3 version has better lighting and colors. The textures pop out more on the PS3 version. The 360 version looks like it has a slight blur filter over it. Some of you guys need to take another look at the video.

ps3 has some deeper blacks but other then that it's the same

One of the few games where the PS3 version is actually better, rather than "the same" or "worse". I'm impressed.

The game is %99.9 percent identical on both platforms. they both have their acheivements/Trophies as well. See EA, if you continue making games PS3 lead platform, i'll continue buying your games. The fact that the game is PS3 lead, means both version Are basically the same, which is what Multi-platform gaming is all about.

Videogamer.com knows how to turn RBG setting to full on ps3 :).

looks like 360 has the washed out colours.

looks like the tables have been turned, and 360 days of "[SUPERIORTY]" is over.

Did anyone here in Canada get it from their EB games? or any store, cause my local Eb tells me that there is no such code here in Canada. Any one want to shed some light on to this matter?

playing it safe. WHY? Because 360 is the 1 with washed out colours wherea PS3 has higher contrast ratio.

Sorry but the tables have turned

xbox looks better :)

Lets compare Console to PC for once -_-

Game looks good on both consoles. PS3 has more color and better lightning. I didn't notice anything different on the 360. AA is the same on both consoles as well.

i liked the PS3 version more cause the brightness on the 360 hurt my eyes a lil bit. But still looks great on both. hmmmmmm i wonder if this is why my eyes were hurting when ever i played on the original Xbox.

Well...

IMHO the PS3 version looks sharp and the contrast it's perfect...

The 360 version looks more or less like PS3 ports last year, lack of contrast and a bit pale...

Something that apparently can be fixed with the TV...

:)

The truth is ps3 looks alot better it looks more real as to the xbox360 it looks more like a video game as to the ps3 it looks more like a movie, honestly it's a brilliant game anyway i'm sure both formats of this game are really welcome to us gamers.

They look identical. Played them both today. You may have to adjust you brightness level depending on your TV settings but in all they are identical. They both have trophies and achievements. The only difference is that they had a collectors edition for 360 and the PS3 version comes with two demos on the disc.

metacritic. The PS3 version is better 9 vs 8.8 in favour of the PS3.

Finally the PS3 gets a descent Multiplatform release! Good one EA! Def picking this up + Mirror's Edge!

but they are fun because you can find out the system that most people back by these stupid comparisons. There is no difference, the only difference happens in exclusives and not in a multiplat.

But I happened to notice that the scene where the main character was running through the corridor. In the x360 version, the character seemed to stand apart from the background where in the ps3 version, he seemed apart of it. The lighting changed the suit color in the ps3 version where as in the x360 version, the character didn't really change as the lighting changed. May have been a fluke in the lighting but it was noticeable.

This game was ps3 lead in development.
Yet, we can't tell that it's a port to the 360.
If it were the other way round, would we say the same?

What must also be noted, is that it costs me $200 +$40 to buy a 360 to play this game, which is identical to the ps3 version which costs $400+$40 to play.

Which is a silly idea?

Same game 360 $240
Same game ps3 $440?

The Ps3 version has 1 more pixel in chest hair and x360 version has 3 more pixels in pubic hair area.

yes i can see past armor