All Channels
Popular
130°

Is the Kinect just a gimmick?

IM PLAYIN discuss the Kinect.

"Once again, Microsoft’s latest console came with a version of the Kinect. And once again that version of Kinect has slowly been phased out by Microsoft. Games aren’t really being developed for it and support for it on the dashboard itself is starting to dwindle – Microsoft are slowly making it easier to use the UI without the need for a Kinect. At the beginning, I was using the Kinect a lot to control my Xbox One, but my enthusiasm slowly wavered; particularly after the Kinect broke and I learnt to live without it. Will Microsoft start to give more support to the Kinect, and introduce more Kinect based games (other than the usual suspects of Kinect Sports, fruit ninja style titles and the dancing games). Or will they let it die a death, as they continue to develop and perfect the HoloLens?"

Read Full Story >>
implayin.co.uk
retrogamer093746d ago

No just underused and underdeveloped. But VR? That's a gimmick.

MCTJim3746d ago

I agree with your first sentence, but I don't think VR is a gimmick, I think its more of a niche product.

eferreira3746d ago

VR is a game changer and everyone I know who's be skeptical about it and then tried it agrees.

MCTJim3746d ago

I have not had the opportunity to use VR and none of the people I know have used it. All we have seen is the demos they have shown, so until I try before I buy, no sale. Hopefully Kiosks will be set up around the time just before it releases.

thisgamer5033745d ago

I disagree. While at first trying VR it feels like a game changer. It's just as easily forgotten about after tinkering with it for a few weeks. VR this gen has Niche written all over it.

DigitalRaptor3745d ago (Edited 3745d ago )

@ 343_Guilty_Spark

3D was a VIEWING option.

VR offers brand new forms of gameplay and new ways for developers and creators to think about game design in interesting ways that questions how our brains work. It's also highly useful in fields outside of gaming, such as medical research, education and tourism. Entertainment is just one strand.

You used a bad example for a rebuttal, but unsurprising you'd try and fail.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 3745d ago
parentoftheyear3746d ago

I agree with your kinect statement. I have one, i bought it to turn on and off my tv. Thats all it does and there is no support for it anymore. Vr a gimmick, i have to disagree with that. It is the future of gaming. Always will be until realistic holograms exist. Its the thing science fiction movies have had in it for decades and for good reason. People want it to be a thing. Sure VR1 isnt going to be the best experience ever, ben gen 2, 3 will just improve until it is ultra real, then we shift to hologram gaming.

retrogamer093746d ago

VR will never replace or complement a gamepad and a couch experience. Plan and simple. It's not the future of gaming and when these things ship people will see this.

kneon3746d ago

And what prevents you from playing a VR game while sitting on your couch and using a controller? That's exactly how most VR games will work.

It's just a different, and hopefully better view that what you get on your TV.

donwel3745d ago

I dunno man, I can see these VR headsets giving people migraines if they're using them for extended gaming sessions, it's a problem nintendo had when they tried VR back in the day. In saying that the tech has come quite a way since then so maybe I'm completely wrong.
At least I hope I'm wrong as I wouldn't like to see VR abandoned like they did with motion control when they realised that people weren't as into it as nintendo, sony and microsoft perhaps wanted them to be.

DigitalRaptor3745d ago

@ Retrogamer09

DUDE.... You are failing all over this thread.

VR can be experienced on a couch and with a controller. In fact on Sony's part PSVR is being designed in a particular manner, with DualShock 4 support being mandatory, and developers being advised on making seated experiences for safety and comfort reasons. You sound just like those people who bag on PC gaming as though you're required to be sat on a chair at a desk outside of the living room.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 3745d ago
FlipSwitch3746d ago Show
rocketpanda3746d ago

So underdeveloped and MS and third party developers couldn't make it work. It has been tried and tested on the 360, PC and Xbox One. There is no excuse. They had to use a Star Wars theme to shift units and even then games were awful.

The kinect is so good it went from mandatory to being optional on the xbox one so MS could shift console units.

The kinect is so good it ruined Steel Battalion and Dragonball Z.

It was so good it gave us Sonic Free Riders.

retrogamer093746d ago

It was so good it's the highest selling game accessory of all time!!!

ShadowKnight3746d ago

@retrogamer09 You really believe that?

rainslacker3745d ago (Edited 3745d ago )

Much of my early career in game development was working with Kinect API's, and writing programs(simulations for research studies and the like) and I can say the device itself was mostly capable with a few shortcomings with the first version.

That being said, the device was only part of the problem. The other problems were API's which weren't all that great from MS...which is why I wrote my own...and the fact that when it comes to game play, motion controls limit more ability than what they open up.

I don't really fault developers for not finding a way to make it work, because motion controls in general really only work for certain kinds of games, and if they're limited, then it limits the games.

Kinect at best was a supplemental device which could add to a game, but there were very few games which could be compelling with nothing but motion controls.

@retro

All that says is that MS did a good job marketing it, not that it was worth anything. The sales mostly came from the casuals, who brought it for things like Just Dance.

Zoombael3746d ago

"VR will never replace or complement a gamepad and a couch experience. Plan and simple. It's not the future of gaming and when these things ship people will see this."

But it will. People who have experienced it know this. You have seen nothing. You know nothing.

DigitalRaptor3745d ago

How is it a gimmick though?

It works, and is blowing minds in alpha demo form. There's no smoke & mirrors or pretence. Now, if MS wanted to get on board with VR, Kinect would be perfectly complimentary to that, because it's a great camera with great tracking. As it stands, everything that Kinect has offered gaming is gimmickry in its most complete and representative form.

You have it all backwards, and that is completely unsurprising to me!

BattleAxe3745d ago

This article is about 2 years behind. I didn't know that Kinect was even a topic anymore....

+ Show (5) more repliesLast reply 3745d ago
Deep-throat3746d ago

I'm jealous of Xbone owners. They still have Kinect games exclusively on Xbone!

PC gamers only got games like QB, Gears and KI :(

retrogamer093746d ago

Thanks for investing in the xbox division with your purchases of those games. We appreciate your money and we'll be making more and more games for xbox one owners while keeping you locked in our windows 10 ecosystem. Win Win.

Liqu1d3745d ago

We? You mean they. You aren't a part of the Xbox division.

gamer78043746d ago

you playing those on OS X , Linux or BeOS? lol

nitus103745d ago (Edited 3745d ago )

Well OSX is an Apple proprietary OS however it does support a huge amount of games and applications.

BeOS was discontinued in November 2001. Of course BeOS does have it's die-hard fans but basically it is a dead OS.

As for Linux, it is an open source Kernel that is used on over a billion mobiles and tablets running the Android OS. Android also has a huge amount of games and software. Linux totally dominates the Super Computer market. It is very popular for use in embedded devices and still dominates in the Server room.

The only area that Linux does not dominate is the Desktop which is basically a Microsoft monopoly, however it is fairly easy to run "Games for Windows" (not the latest though) as well as some MS Windows centric software (there are alternatives though) under compatibility software. The market for native Linux games for the Desktop is slowly growing mainly due to SteamOS.

gamer78043745d ago

@nitus10

Lol thanks, my statement was rhetorical 😊

skydragoonityx3746d ago (Edited 3746d ago )

The kinect is all shades of gimmick.

Orionsangel3746d ago (Edited 3746d ago )

It's definitely a gimmick when developers create games around it just to show off what it can do. This would be fine if they did this when it launches but it goes on for years. Every game starts to feel like a technical demo to show off what the Kinect can do. In other words the games exist around what the Kinect can do. A game is forcefully created to show off the Kinect. Rather than just be a game that happens to use the Kinect.

rainslacker3745d ago

Ironically, the actual tech demo of it, and one reason people hyped it up so much, never came to fruition.

poppinslops3746d ago

For me, it just makes stuff simpler - it turns my xbox on, logs me in, it's great for voice chat, scanning qr codes is easier than typing in numbers and it lets me control my console while I'm eating/drinking/smoking/mastur ba... watching movies.

I could care less about motion controlled gaming, but I would like to see more in-game voice commands - Mass Effect 3 used Kinect as an alternate way of controlling squadmates, eliminating the need to pause during combat... intuitive things like that and Forza's head-tracking can be used to augment a game's experience.

kneon3746d ago

We often hear people defend Kinect by saying how useful the voice commands are. I won't argue whether or not that is useful, but if that is the main feature then they could have accomplished the same thing with a $20 microphone.

Bigpappy3745d ago (Edited 3745d ago )

Not at all. You don't have to ware a Kinect. You don't have to touch anything. It is great for snapping and recording gaming moments(Faster than using a controller). Plus Kinect sees you and logs you in. Still supported for dance and fitness tiles. Kids and ladies love the dancing. The fitness is there if you ever want to tighten up a bit. Now you don't need to buy it if you don't see the need for it.

kneon3745d ago

Yes the camera has it's uses, it's just that most people don't seem to have much use for that feature.

rainslacker3745d ago

What I see in your comment is talking about what perks it can bring, and those are certainly nice, but what I don't see is how those make games any better, or make it worth having for games. To me, at least in context, that is the very definition of a gimmick. Maybe it's not quite past that point, since controlling your console can be done while in game, but makes it just another way to achieve something. That in itself is fine, but early on, when it was a major selling point, it comes across as kind of gimmicky.

nitus103745d ago

The PS4 actually supports voice commands via the Dual Shock 4 with a simple mono headset and microphone that comes standard with PS4.

Granted that the Kinect supports voice commands better but it is an additional expense.

In addition the DS4 does have a touch-pad which actually works and makes data entry quicker, however so far I have not seen the touch-pad utilised in many games. In The Witcher 3 a swipe of the touch-pad will bring up the map but this is the only example of touch[ad utilisation I have seen in PS4 games.

Show all comments (70)
70°

Microsoft Gaming Revenue Drops 7% Year-on-Year, Content and Services Down 5%, Xbox Hardware Down 33%

Microsoft announced its financial results for Q3 of fiscal year 2026, including an update on its gaming Xbox business and more.

Read Full Story >>
simulationdaily.com
Jin_Sakai24d ago (Edited 24d ago )

Not looking good. Hopefully Asha Sharma is able to turn Phil’s disaster around.

dveio24d ago

To me it's still quite remarkable how they can cash-in 5.3bn in revenue in a single quarter, since their hardware is basically dead.

Jingsing24d ago

The stock mark is what makes Microsoft remarkable, They have convinced every institutional and retail investor to just keep piling money into them. Like many big tech giants they are just a big growing pyramid scheme. As long as people keep dropping money into ETF's that cover the market Microsoft will always be liquid. At the same time it is completely stifling innovation and competition. People need to start being more discreet in how they invest their money as it's killing the system.

Tanktopmaster9224d ago

Once they re-evaluate exclusive all will be fine….

S2Killinit24d ago

Riiiiight because people will just flock back to them for one or two games per year.

Jingsing24d ago

15+ years of bad performance is what they call irreparable in business. It is time for them to sell off the assets and get out of entertainment.

Tanktopmaster9224d ago

These declines are on the back of extra revenue received from releasing games like Forza horizon 5 on PlayStation. So I’m being sarcastic here when I said they should go back to exclusives. Killing off a revenue stream from Ps5 sales will only make things worse

Show all comments (13)
70°

Xbox boss: Memory crisis could impact next-gen hardware pricing

Xbox boss Asha Sharma has discussed how component shortages will impact the company's plans for Project Helix.

Read Full Story >>
gamedeveloper.com
Eonjay26d ago

When does this end? Its killing everyone. Consoles and PC. And for what? AI? The benefits of AI are completely outweighed by the negatives. And the government should have never allowed one company to buy up all the RAM.

Lexreborn226d ago

This kind of proves this is an after thought product, most products like this are in r&d 5 years before they start mass producing. So they typically have the cost of components and things worked out long before assembly starts.

This is an assumption still, but I wouldn’t be surprised if project helix is similar to Scalebound,perfect dark and sod3. They had an idea but no actual execution other than concept stage. Being impacted by the ram shortage likely would also put this device 3-4 years out.

I’m not even sure MS has that endurance with Xbox yet

Fishy Fingers26d ago (Edited 26d ago )

I mean.... what?

We're at a point that Samsung wont even provide their own phone department ram because they can sell it at higher prices to 3rd parties (AI). Its more profitable to sell the ram than make their own devices with it.

You think because R&D starts 5 years ago the 3rd party component manufacturers will honour that price? They'll sell it to whomever is paying the most today, not some gentlemens agreement they made years ago. AI farms will buy more volume at higher prices than any console manufacturer will. It'll be the same for Playstation.

Lexreborn226d ago

Contractual agreements are not the same as “gentlemen” agreements. If you think that they work with their distributors a month before production then their entire business model is trash. They work with companies like nvidia constantly for building the graphics cards they need. They work with companies that build motherboards years in advance. This is what proper business planning does.

They are not buying components on a whim like a consumer. So again, considering the ram isn’t a singular module and is integrated into the motherboard I highly doubt they wouldn’t have a final schematic that they are supposed to be building around.

If they are delaying production another 3 years then it’s obvious again this is an after though project and is just trying to be responsive to their bad execution they had the last 14 years.

It also isn’t far fetched to use their failure to produce first party titles the last 7 years including the highly anticipated games I mentioned all being cancelled. That they would continue to you know… lie

Sitdown26d ago

You don't really know how this works huh?

Profchaos26d ago (Edited 26d ago )

Helix is going to be stupidly expensive

Instead of leaning into smarter upscaling techniques they're brute forcing hardware that will cost them dearly and it remains to be seen if it's genuinely going to provide a meaningful differential

I know in the oc.doace people like to brag about not using frame gen or dlss to get to high on a game but for the majority of players they happily use those technologies without a second thought

That's going to be ps6 vs Helix

Eonjay26d ago

Yeah with FSR 5 they should be able to offer a much cheaper version of Helix.

Eonjay26d ago

While this does seem to be the case, I am encouraged by the statement from Microsoft about wanting to provide affordable options. If this means a Series S style Helix, at least there will be something affordable being offered.

XBManiac25d ago

Series S is what has killed Xbox Series so... Will they dare?

blacktiger26d ago

It's called systematic inflationary. Yes we get it Microsoft, keep raising in the name ofall kinds of stuffs

pwnmaster300026d ago

Honestly if there was thing I learned from this generation is that new consoles arnt day one anymore.
I can wait 1-3 years.

DarXyde26d ago

Another important lesson from this generation: while Nintendo showed us that prices don't necessarily need to ever drop, we've now learned that waiting 1-3 years does carry some risk that prices increase. This generation is just bizarre in all the wrong ways.

LucasRuinedChildhood26d ago (Edited 26d ago )

The factors are largely external. Covid and Russia-Ukraine war causing inflation led to the first price increase in 2022.

Then we get Trump's tariffs increasing hardware prices, AI boom causing a RAM crisis, war on Iran causing a worldwide fuel crisis which impacts the cost of everything.

Gaming doesn't exist in a vacuum. The last few years have been a shitshow and lot of it was definitely avoidable.

DarXyde26d ago

LucasRuinedChildhood,

For sure. No disagreement on the external factors doing a lot of this. Where I have to gently push back however is on two fronts:

1. The pandemic definitely caused some issues: asynchronous development was a big issue and really complicated timelines and affected game quality. At the same time, when it comes to price hikes, it's really difficult to know what was genuine necessity and what was taking consumers for a ride. The pandemic brought about "stag-flation" which was increasing prices and stagnant wages, which was a problem caused by supply chain constraints. There was also "Greed-flation", where companies that were slightly affected or had no issues took advantage of the situation and squeezed everyone citing supply chain issues when there were none.

2. It's definitely true that the tariffs, AI boom, and RAM crisis were all things enabled by tech broligarchs throwing money at this caricature of a world leader, one of them being Satya Nadella. I don't think Sony and Nintendo have contributed much to this problem if at all, but Microsoft's Nadella I feel was instrumental in causing every one of those issues. Microsoft as a company contributed to both candidates (though they gave Harris 4x as much if I recall), but Nadella was all in on letting AI run wild. He paid for unregulated AI, and got a war that's not a war (even though Trump called it that at least five times on television) that screwed up helium access. So for me, I feel that one of the players in the gaming industry is a key architect of these issues, and for that reason I struggle a bit to think of it as "external".

Show all comments (28)
50°

'The big things that we're thinking about'

In an exclusive interview with Game File, new(ish) Xbox boss Asha Sharma and Xbox chief content officer Matt Booty explain their vision for Microsoft’s gaming division

Read Full Story >>
gamefile.news
Agent7527d ago

A good start would be to release games to go with the console. My Xbox Series X has gathered dust virtually from launch. My advice would be to ditch a next console and release games on PC, PlayStation and Switch. Another idea would be a hybrid console based on Xbox Series X tech and go the same route as Nintendo. Another idea would be to pull out of gaming altogether. Plenty of options there.

Reaper22_25d ago

Why would they pull out? They have the momentum. Sony has been getting nothing but bad news lately.