All Channels
Popular
150°

Why RPGs Aren't Really RPGs Anymore

Games like Fallout, Mass Effect, and Fable are some examples of games that pride themselves on the player's choices and how it affects the game's world itself. But it seems that in recent years, the weight behind these decisions and how it changes the player have not been at the forefront of developers' minds. After playing Undertale, I realized how RPGs have gone from morally and mentally challenging experiences to games that feel hollow and empower the character rather than the player.

Read Full Story >>
se7ensins.com
LAWSON723793d ago

Mass effect 2 and 3 are not RPGs, they are third person shooters.

TFJWM3793d ago

If Fallout 3/4 are RPGs then so are Mass effect 2 and 3, you might have more options in one over the other but both are still RPGs

Qrphe3793d ago

The new Fallout games are shadows of the rpgs they used to be, specially 4. Fallout 4 is about a man who looks for his son in a strictly linear plot. It's a sandbox shooter with RPG elements.

3-4-53793d ago

* I don't that Mass Effect aren't full RPG's.....They are fun games for whatever they are.

A Game's genre label means nothing to me. I care how much I enjoy playing it.

muffinbutton3793d ago

id say its a 3rd person shooter with some rpg like elements.

3793d ago
+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 3793d ago
TheColbertinator3793d ago

Seems like it. Shooters with RPG elements.

On the other hand Todd Howard(Bethesda) said that more games are picking up RPG elements such as Call of Duty with XP and leveling up

Feyfolken3793d ago (Edited 3793d ago )

That's true, though using traditional RPG elements like leveling and experience is pretty prevalent in any multiplayer game. My thoughts were more centered on the games that pride themselves on being an RPG with dynamic decisions and game-changing choices when that's not really the case.

Don't get me wrong, I love Fallout and Mass Effect and every game that I bashed in that article, but I don't think it's fair to say they're an RPG when they're really shooters with RPG-esque elements.

Fist4achin3793d ago

@TheColbertinator I am in much agreement with you re: shooters with rpg elements. They have taken a lot of the most important elements to give them something to strive for instead of just point and shoot, over and over. Shooters can be fun too when the story is written well, but I prefer rpg games overall.

UlyssesFeral3793d ago

This article seems to be mistitled, having more to do with morality systems than the definition of a role-playing game. And ultimately, it just reads like a plug for Undertale. I'm sure Undertale is a fine game, but I don't appreciate mislabeled content. Better titles for the piece: "How Undertale Gets Morality Systems Right" or "How An Indie Title Outshines Every AAA Choice-Driven RPG". Not so hard.

Gwiz3793d ago

The definition of RPG is not so much based on older turn-based mechanics (Japanese) or the Western variant of game-play.
Both regions have been mixing all kinds of interpretations of roleplaying.
I had this discussion a few days ago about how roleplaying is not region and playstyle defined but rather a developing character and gathering of skills.So yes i totally agree with your consensus.

Feyfolken3793d ago

Fair enough. In my view, with a lot of open world games priding themselves on making choices and changing the game world, it seemed to me that Fallout 4 (as an example) did not really deliver on those aspects that we expect to see in Fallout or any other RPG for that matter. Undertale was heavily referenced because of its ingenuity, as well as how it was executed which was entirely better than most other games.

RPGs don't make me feel involved or immersed in a role and there is very little weight behind any decisions made in these games nowadays. It's not really mislabeled, you just don't share my opinion, that's all.

Adrian_v013793d ago

It is a misleading title. The article isn't about RPG's not being RPG's, it's about games that don't have a good developed morality system in your opinion. It has nothing to do with RPGs not being RPGs.

KingKionic 3793d ago

Nah sounds like you just enjoyed the undertale story.

Witcher 3 and Fallout 4 the crowning rpg`s of 2015.

There as rpg as you can get.

Both have morale implications to all choices you take.

Tex1173793d ago

I mean...Witcher 3 yes, but not for Fallout 4 really.

You get to choose what faction you want but that is about it.

Show all comments (23)
40°

Get An Exclusive Fallout Bottlecap At Fallout Exhibit Event In Las Vegas

The Fallout Exhibit in Las Vegas is offering fans a limited Edition Bottlecap during a special event.

180°

Mass Effect - N7 DAY 2025

Bioware writes: "Like you, we’ve heard the rumors lately. You’ve made it clear you care deeply about what’s next. So let’s start by setting the record straight: the next Mass Effect game is in development, and EA and BioWare remain committed to telling more stories in this universe."

Read Full Story >>
blog.bioware.com
-Foxtrot191d ago

I expected nothing and I'm still disappointed

Like with Fallout, it's starting to feel studios are using TV / Film adaptations when they have no game info to talk about.

toxic-inferno191d ago

I feel the same way.

I mean, how difficult would it be for them to release SOMETHING of substance? Another short trailer? A couple of proper hints? A short story set during the original trilogy, but focused on fringe characters?

Hopefully they're working so hard on the game that they don't have time. But still, with every passing year and so little to show, the franchise will be slipping further and further from people's minds.

Profchaos191d ago

Yeah agree it's almost a cop out since Dev times are 5 to 10 years just throw out a few seasons instead you get them done in a year

jznrpg191d ago

I still haven’t beat Andromeda. I am waiting for a lull of good games in my backlog

P_Bomb191d ago

So the TV show will take place after the OG trilogy. I wonder which ending they’ll use?

Rebel_Scum191d ago

Should’ve just posted a picture of an Elcor saying “regretfully, we have nothing to share.”

Show all comments (11)
40°

World Of Fallout Exhibit Announced

A new Fallout exhibition has been revealed for fans.