
Evolve has drawn criticism from gamers and game journalists, primarily because of the downloadable content (DLC) strategy that has been employed for the game. A good example of this criticism, in part because it cites some of the other critics, is the recent Forbes article by Erik Kain.
According to these criticisms, Turtle Rock, previously best known for developing Left 4 Dead with Valve, and 2K have short-changed gamers by not selling a complete game. Instead, content has been held back to be sold as DLC in a blatant attempt to milk gamers out of extra dollars. These criticisms are unfair.

It has been recently revealed by an artist that a sequel to the 2015 title Evolve was in the works. However, this project wouldn't last long.
Was this game ahead of its time? A few years later games like Dead By Daylight, Friday the 13th and other asymmetrical games exploded onto the scene.

Back in 2016, Turtle Rock announced that support for its 4v1 monster-hunting shooter Evolve would end but fans wouldn't let it die.

From NME: "Evolve: Stage 2 had its multiplayer servers shut down back in 2018, but today players are once again able to matchmake and join peer-to-peer multiplayer games.
Several months ago, peer-to-peer functionality was lost for Evolve Legacy, which was the only way fans of the series could play with friends. Upon a multitude of players reaching out to publisher 2K, the issue was eventually fixed earlier in July. It seems 2K have gone a step further now, and reinstated peer-to-peer and matchmaking functionality for Evolve: Stage 2 after four years."
"So, what is this extra content that is being offered? That $61 of DLC that is available now; it’s all skins. There are weapon skins for the hunters and skins for the monsters. But they are just skins. No perks like a higher fire rate on the weapons or greater armor for the monsters. It’s cosmetic.
Therefore, the answer to the second question (How would not buying this content effect the experience of playing the game?) depends on how important you think skins are. This DLC does not affect how the weapons or monsters play at all; the gameplay is the same whether you have these skins or not."
"While people are harping on Turtle Rock and 2K charging for skins (a common practice) they quickly skip over that there will be no charge for additional maps and game modes."
As Eddie Beal wrote, would you be happier if, for Evolve, Turtle Rock and 2K reversed themselves and gave away the skins but charged for the additional maps (i.e. used the traditional DLC model)?
I would not.