All Channels
Popular
150°
3.0

Knack review | Edge

Sony’s extensive collection of production studios has never succeeded in creating a family-friendly action game to stand alongside the finest Mario adventures, but that hasn’t stopped them trying. And that makes Knack’s failings all the more galling.

Read Full Story >>
edge-online.com
Mikey322304559d ago

I hate reviews that do this... the game cant be that bad. These games are not that bad.

The only logical reason i can see in why you would rate a game like knack so low is because of its price, and your experience with it.

Yes its probably not worth $60.. but it if were a $15 game it would deserve a higher rating.

Concertoine4559d ago

If it was a 1 id agree. But if you say something like "oh if it were 15 bucks it would deserve a higher rating" then you know the game is sub par.
Id give it a 5, tops. Its just not much good, imo.

abzdine4559d ago

This game is FIRE!!!
it is so nicely made with a nice story and solid gameplay.
Definitely my best PS4 game until i really play Killzone seriously.

NewMonday4559d ago

@Concertoine

when you say "IMO" that should mean you have a a PS4 and played the game, if not some may call what you do trolling.

Hatsune-Miku4559d ago

Lol. Reviews are useless in the gaming industry. I love this game and feel like it doesn't deserve a score less than an average rating. People these days think games should be catered to their likings instead of rating a game on its own merits. Constantly I see reviewers bring up facts about how A game isn't like B game so it's a fail. There will barely be growth in the gaming industry because deva will continue to walk a line of conformity to be like what's seen as popular.

A lot of games fall victim to low scoring just for being too different fresh

Concertoine4559d ago (Edited 4559d ago )

@NewMonday
I do not own a ps4, plan on getting one next year. But played through the game at my friends house over the first 2 days after launch. Not trolling. I would not be giving my opinion of a game i havent played :P.
Not sure why me giving a negative opinion is immediatly suspected as trolling. All im saying is a 3 isnt completely implausible. Just like it isnt implausible in regards to Ryse.

NewMonday4559d ago

@Concertoine

nice that you admit that, then you should leave the evaluation of games to people who play them fully, user reviews on Metacritic and Amazon are positive.

funny how those how don't have a PS4 are constantly handing out scores for games, maybe because the PS4 is dominating conversations and nobody cares to talk about anything else, for example SM3DW just released and nobody noticed, to bad.

Concertoine4559d ago

@NewMonday
Excuse me? I played through the game, beginning to end at launch, how can i play it more "fully"? The user score is 6.6 on metacritic. How is that good. The critic score isnt even far off at 5.5
And all these critics played this game "fully," and many called it a meh game. Maybe this corridor platformer, simple-minded button mash brawler with unimpressive graphics and story just wasnt very good, huh?
Look man, if you like the game that's great. But branding me a troll for disliking it is totally wrong. And don't say its for infants or something, it has E 10+ right on the box, and kids games like spyro and crash can be fun at any age.

NewMonday4559d ago (Edited 4559d ago )

@Concertoine

so you "played" the game fully in 2 days at a "friends house"?

so..

A) the game can't be that bad to hold you captivated so strong it compels you to go all the way to a "friend's house" and play it for 10 hours in just 2 days.

or

B) that did not happen, and your not being honest, this is not your first offense you are building a reputation already.

+ Show (5) more repliesLast reply 4559d ago
Hicken4559d ago

I think it's telling that comments are disabled for the article.

They know they did wrong, and don't want anybody to point it out to them.

JonnyBigBoss4559d ago

Such a bad software launch. Sony, what were you thinking?

solidsheep4559d ago

They probably though it was a good idea to still support last gen with games and not drop complete support.

Visiblemarc4559d ago

This stuff us BS. Judge Knack for yourself. It is about a 7. Reviewers are getting so damn annoying lately, acting too cool for school.

Kayant4559d ago

Because MS's is infinitely better??

No but seriously I don't see how XB1's is anything better because the only game that really interests me is DR3 & maybe Ryse. The rest I won't personally even consider.

JonnyBigBoss4559d ago

I'm addicted to Forza 5 and Dead Rising 3. My PS4 is a Netflix box for now.

DigitalRaptor4559d ago (Edited 4559d ago )

If Sony had decided to drain support of their PS3 and instead launched Gran Turismo 6, Puppeteer and The Last of Us on PS4 - that would've been one of the best launch lineups. EVER.

But fortunately, Sony is not that kind of company to drain support, and PS3 is still seeing a healthy flow of first party support. And they are exactly where they need to be at this early stage in the generation -- global market domination, a great console with lots of great things coming, including the games we all know about, and those we don't.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 4559d ago
Kos-Mos4559d ago

Is this a symbol of: "Can`t wait for PS4 release in november!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!&q uot;

Studio-YaMi4559d ago

Yeah because Edge reviews are so relevant for anything other than cheap hits.

I have the game,played through it,it's a nice game with simplified gaming mechanics,it is designed that way to appeal to the casual gamers.

Me personally,I would give this game a 6/10 just for the adventure.(playing it on Hard difficulty).

KiRBY30004559d ago

not really. all launch games arent cult classics.

mandf4559d ago

LittleBigPlanet says hi. It got a 10 from them. It also won their game of the year. Grade the game on its own merits not other games.

caseh4559d ago

It's like a nice little tech demo with no substance, if there are other games that do exactly what this does, only a lot better then the score for this game is deservedly low.

if it were to be rated on its own merits, then the graphics are about the only thing going in its favour. It's pretty crap.

mandf4559d ago

is the game broken?no a scale 0f 1 to 10 is used. a 5 should be average anything below that is broken. if you dont agree with any of that, then the review system is broken.

caseh4559d ago

I agree, the review system is broken. If i'm gonna be honest, I probably wouldn't go below 5 as it really isn't my kind of game. I don't review games as I can't be that impartial about stuff that doesn't impress me.

It's quite apparent reviews system is a joke when games are given 10/10 or 100/100. Go back to past console gen reviews in magazines and such, I can't recall a single game that got a PERFECT score through the genesis/SNES/PSX/Saturn etc.

These days, something that's seen as crap gets levelled by reviewers yet AC, COD etc are getting flawless scores over and over again.

mandf4559d ago

Nice reply. It's nice have a conversation without fanboy stuff. The game is competent. I'm with you though not my style. The only thing I can point out is music is also not flawed.

caseh4559d ago

I don't do fan-boy wars, i'm here for the games! :)

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 4559d ago
Show all comments (53)
270°

Sony Files New Trademark Fuelling Knack 3 Speculations

Sony might be gearing to launch a new Knack game, a franchise that has had received quite a polarizing reception from the community.

Read Full Story >>
dualshockers.com
deleted1518d ago (Edited 1518d ago )

While I did actually enjoy the Knack games, and found the reviews overly harsh, I do feel 2 games were enough unless the series was revitalized in a major way. For me, that would be a new Knack game for PSVR2. With the increased hardware power, those HD particle effects would be pretty awesome, surrounding the player at times. Astrobot proved that platformers can be amazing in VR, so let's hope that's where they're going with this, if real!

_SilverHawk_1518d ago

Hopefully sony makes a knack 3 because the previous games were amazing.

MoonConquistador1517d ago

Knack was a few things, but amazing wasn't one of them.

TiredGamer1518d ago

Agreed there. I went into Knack with the realization that it was a simple platform/brawler (i.e. something akin to a Crash Bandicoot style of simplicity). My friend and I thoroughly enjoyed the co-op for what it was. Fun to play in short bursts to take a break from the more serious fare out there. I haven’t played Knack 2, but my understanding was that many of the original’s shortfalls were addressed there.

jznrpg1518d ago

Great idea . PSVR2 could make Lnack really shine like Astro Bot

MoonConquistador1517d ago

Astrobot was a likeable character. Knack wasn't.

coolbeans1518d ago

Translation: the next best game of all time is coming soon! Show me the money, Knack!

Army_of_Darkness1517d ago (Edited 1517d ago )

Lol! I have both knack 1-2. Second one is fun local co-op action, but to be honest, I don't care for a third installment. I'd rather have a new resistance game!

MoonConquistador1517d ago

I'd rather have an enema than a new knack game.

A new killzone, resistance, motorstorm, driveclub or even a days gone sequel would be more welcomed than flogging any more life from the knack series.

badz1491518d ago

speak for yourself!

bring it on, Sony!

coolbeans1518d ago

There's been a Knack-sized hole in every gamer's heart since 2 came and went.

deleted1518d ago (Edited 1518d ago )

I completely read this comment wrong, but I'll refrain from explaining. XD

Edit - ah screw it... My heart can't wait for Knack to come into that hole for a third time!

deleted1518d ago

@PS-Gamer-1986 Whaaa? You don't have a Knack hole? XD

PhoenixRoar1518d ago

Surprised to see them continue this but considering how invested they are in the IP and the wider appeal, there must be some commercial sense to continue with a 3rd title

rippermcrip1518d ago

My young kids love playing it. I don't know why all these older people are complaining about it.

jznrpg1518d ago

I played them with my younger children and we had a good time .

Lexreborn21517d ago

This… my kids love knack probably more then other mascots. And that’s probably because that’s their generations mascot. It’s undeniable ps4 spoke to a lot of children the last decade more then other competitors that have only been in kids sight for the last 4-5 years.

My kids will flip if this news is real

lellkay1518d ago

Both games were actually alright.

Show all comments (44)
120°

Top 10 Best Japan Studios Games

Alex S. from Link Cable Gaming writes: "Over the last 26 years, Japan Studio has delivered some of the marquee games for the PlayStation family of consoles and gave us some of our favorite gaming memories. So as Japan Studios sails off into the sunset, we wanted to dedicate a Top 10 article to the best Japan Studios games, ever."

Read Full Story >>
linkcablegaming.com
darthv721896d ago

Loved locoroco and legend of dragoon. Never played gravity rush or even ape escape but I heard good things.

ThePacemaker1896d ago

ICO and shadow of Colossus are the best ever.

270°

No More Memes: It's Time For Knack 3 On PS5

Beyond the memes, Knack is just a solid platformer that deserves a new home on the PlayStation 5.

Read Full Story >>
culturedvultures.com
lifeisgamesok2039d ago

I'd rather they make a new platformer IP. With Sackboy and Astro's Playroom PS5 looks very good for the platformer genre so far

SullysCigar2039d ago

Agreed. Astro Bot Rescue Mission is honestly one on the best platformers I've ever played. It took things to the next level and was a delight from start to finish!

That said, while I was happily laughing along with the "Knack 2 baby!" memes with everyone else, I have to say I was a bit shocked when they gave it out free on PS Plus and I actually played it...it was actually really enjoyable lol

And huge too. Really long, loads of replayability and upgrade trees, new powers, costumes, challenge modes...hate to admit it, but I'd be pretty pleased with a Knack 3 announcement now!

Relientk772039d ago

Also Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart, Balan Wonderworld, Crash Bandicoot 4 (probably), and Spyro 4 is rumored to be in development

PS5 is looking great for platformers

isarai2039d ago

I think it would be great if they rebooted it, keep the visual style, but change the tone of the story and voices to match. This game looks like it should have a semi mute protagonist with a silly professor and his rebellious apprentice. Instead knack sounds like a brainwashed soldier, the professor like an angry divorced dad, and the kid is such an average joe. And the story takes itself way too seriously, it's so clashing with it's art style

lukasmain2039d ago

Thye don't need Knack they got Sackboy. He'll kill it

ApocalypseShadow2039d ago (Edited 2039d ago )

It's time for Ape Escape PS5, Dual Sense Enhanced.

Give me that first. Then whatever.

GaboonViper2039d ago

Couldn't agree more, i remember the first time playing Ape Escape with the Dual Shock, great times, we need a PS5 version.

ApocalypseShadow2038d ago

Yeah. I didn't know a controller could do so much until that game.

MadLad2039d ago

It's really not.
The first really didn't deserve a sequel, and the sequel, itself, was nothing special.

Show all comments (19)