All Channels
Popular
70°

Morality Systems Need to be Less Black & White

Sean Halliday of Pixel Gate writes:

''This generation has seen decision-making and morality systems play major parts in a lot of games. The likes of Mass Effect and Fallout 3 have all featured them in some shape or form. While both games are ‘good’ examples of morality systems, they all tend to suffer from the same issue–and it’s an issue that affects almost every single game with a system of this nature.''

Read Full Story >>
pixelgate.co.uk
-Gespenst-4604d ago

Morality systems in games are usually binarisms. If there were like 4 different choices, that could mean a LOT more work. Not that I disagree with this article's proposition - on the contrary I wholeheartedly agree - but there's probably a practical reason for the simplcity of morality systems in games. That's not to say that the views of the creators themselves couldn't influence such a feature either; sometimes it could even be both. Nonetheless, people shouldn't let their games mislead them into thinking the complexity morality is even nearly approximated by such games. Heck, I could say the same about most games, morality system or no.

Pixelgate4604d ago

Hwy Gespenst, thanks for the comment!

While i do agree it would take a ton more work to create a truly in depth morality system but with morality systems becoming even more of a common mechanic in games surely someone will step up to the plate?

That being said The Witcher 2 does a decent job of having a less 'in your face' morality system that goes beyond being a toss up between pure evil choices and some kind of paragon of justice and truth!

wheresmymonkey4604d ago

Its already been done, Look at the likes of The Witcher seires and Deus Ex, and to a lesser extent Skyrim and Fallout.

All of these games contain a morality system as in their are options which are good and options that are morally questionale.

But at the end of the day they don't make any great difference except to who will accosiate with yuo and who wont.

Making a decent morality system is simple, it just has to present choice with no actual consequence other than minor societal ones as at the end of the day morality is merely a social construct and should be treated as such in games.

DeadManV4604d ago

It would probably easier for games without voice acting

Pintheshadows4604d ago (Edited 4604d ago )

The Witcher 3 should fix this. The morality system seems to affect people and regions, not a bar that slides back and forth.

MightyNoX4604d ago

Witcher series does it well.

Roccetarius4604d ago

Well, i wouldn't expect devs like Bioware to pick up on this. CDPR is doing pretty well in that area, and Witcher 3 will most likely raise that bar.

AceBlazer134604d ago

the walking dead pulls it off imo. evey decision i make has me questioning choice. would be cool the day we get to respond through mics ourselves , within another decade probably

Show all comments (10)
50°

Fable Retrospective: A Look Back At The Classic Franchise

The Outerhaven writes: Being fans of Fable, we decided to do an in-depth retrospective on the Fable franchise, exploring its choices, consequences, tone, and lasting impact on RPG design.

Read Full Story >>
theouterhaven.net
Alos88137d ago

I'd play remasters if they did em'

darthv72137d ago

that is what fable anniversary is.

50°

Fable Retrospective: A Look Back At The Classic Franchise

The Outerhaven writes: An in-depth retrospective on the Fable franchise, exploring its choices, consequences, tone, and lasting impact on RPG design.

Read Full Story >>
theouterhaven.net
120°

Next ‘BioShock’ Game Changes Leaders After Development Turmoil

The fourth game in the ‘BioShock’ series has been in development for more than a decade

Read Full Story >>
bloomberg.com
toxic-inferno309d ago

Bioshock is one of my favourites franchises. I love all 3 games and have played each several times. I even have a room in my house that is loosely decorated around the theme of Bioshock (with a Lighthouse, coral models and postcards styled as though they are from both Rapture and Columbus).

And yet I am going to find it extremely difficult to get even remotely excited about any future episode in the series after all the problems this has had in its development cycle.

Leave the franchise alone. Remaster them again if you have to. Then put whatever talent you have to use on something brand new.

Furesis309d ago

Since ken levine isn't involved i'm not surprised what's going on. i'm more excited for his next game which looks like bioshock. Yet he still works under take2 and they are making bioshock 4 without him, strange situation.

toxic-inferno309d ago

Yes. Judas. Looks brilliant, but it's one of those games that seems to never have had a release date. Instead it's had release windows that keep getting pushed back.

Once it's ready, I'll be there for it though. Ken Levine is an excellent developer.

I get the feeling he dissolved Irrational Games simply so that 2k couldn't tell him what to do. It seems it will pay off, but I feel sorry for those who worked as part of Irrational before it was dissolved, who hadn't independently made a name for themselves.

ActualWhiteMan308d ago

He didn’t even want to make 2, that’s why they did it without him.

Rebel_Scum308d ago

tbh it wouldnt be a Bioshock game without development hell. They all had it.

Michiel1989308d ago

bioshock 2 was 2.5 years after 1, so much of a development hell it was......

-Foxtrot308d ago

"Remaster them again if you have to"

Well apparently they were doing a remake but that got cancelled

Relientk77309d ago

It sucks this game is in development hell because I love BioShock and would love a 4th game. I hope it turns out great, but I guess we'll see.

P_Bomb309d ago

Love Bioshock. It’s too bad what’s going on. At least we have Judas.

Yui_Suzumiya308d ago (Edited 308d ago )

It's been in development hell since 2014. This is nothing new. It saddens me because it's one of my favorite series. At this point, Judas may end up releasing first.

BABI-PANGPANG308d ago

Bioshock 4 (if it ever comes out) will probably still look and play like a Bioshock game, but without Kevin, it might miss that spark that made the originals so special. Honestly, Judas might end up feeling more like the real spiritual successor.